Voting Rights · Report · File No. 261118-089
Law firm for GOP candidates asks Ohio counties to toss ballots LaRose's rules allowed
A Cincinnati law firm working for Republican candidates wants county election boards to throw out ballots from voters who moved within Ohio. Those voters cast their ballots the way Secretary of State Frank LaRose's instructions told them to. Close Ohio House races could turn on the outcome.
Every quote in this story (3) was matched word for word against its source. How we work

Two weeks after Election Day, a Cincinnati law firm working for Republican candidates is asking Ohio county election boards to throw out provisional ballots. These ballots came from registered voters who moved from one Ohio county to another, did not update their registration, and then voted at their new neighborhood polling place 12. Voting rights groups say thousands of ballots could be affected 1.
A provisional ballot is a backup ballot. Poll workers hand it out when a voter's eligibility needs to be checked, for example when the voter's name or address is not in the poll book. Election officials review each one before deciding whether to count it.
The firm, Taft Stettinius & Hollister, says these voters were only allowed to cast provisional ballots at a county board of elections office or another site the board chose, not at regular precincts 4. But Secretary of State Frank LaRose, a Republican, put out guidance for this year's midterms saying such voters could vote provisionally at their polling places 1. Taft's letters say that guidance was wrong 1.
Where the fight stands
Aaron Ockerman is executive director of the Ohio Association of Election Officials, a group for county election staff. He said he knows of six counties that got the letters, all with close state legislative or county commissioner races 2. Two of those counties have already voted on the request and deadlocked, he said. That leaves the final decision to LaRose 2.
From Channel GOPAmy Acton on the ad that made Ohioans think Vivek doesn't share their Amy Acton · 274 plays · captioned, with the source named
One of those deadlocks was in Hamilton County, which includes Cincinnati. On Tuesday, Nov. 17, its board split along party lines over whether to throw out the ballots, so LaRose will cast the deciding vote 3. The ballots could matter in State House District 29, where Republican Rep. Cindy Abrams of Harrison leads Democrat Jonathan Bradner by 19 votes 3.
In Lucas County, which includes Toledo, Taft filed a four-page objection late Sunday, Nov. 15, for Republican Edward Schimmel, who is running in Ohio House District 44 4. The objection gave the board until Nov. 17 to respond and said the firm reserves the right to seek court relief 4. As of noon Wednesday, Schimmel led Democrat David Fournier by 33 votes, and the race was still too close to call 1.
The Lucas County board met behind closed doors on Monday, Nov. 16. It approved 835 provisional ballots cast at the early vote center and 1,540 cast on Election Day after confirming those voters had not already voted 4. Lucas County officials said provisional ballots from voters who moved within Ohio can be counted once they are verified 1.
you can't put that genie back in the bottle
Voting groups push back
On Nov. 17, the League of Women Voters of Ohio and the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) of Ohio wrote to all 88 county boards and to LaRose. They urged officials to count the ballots as the secretary's own directive allows 6. The groups warned that rejecting the ballots would violate voters' rights under the First and Fourteenth Amendments to the U.S. Constitution 1.
Secretary LaRose's instructions to the county Boards of Elections are crystal clear.
The groups also argued that if a poll worker sent a voter to the wrong place, fixing that mistake is the job of election officials, not the voter 5. Their press release said Taft was using "hypertechnical legal theories and red tape" as "an excuse to throw out the ballots of hundreds of eligible Ohio voters." 5
Elections officials must reject this partisan request to invalidate provisional votes.
Taft's argument relies on the wording of Ohio law. In its Lucas County letter, the firm wrote, "The Board should reject that category of ballots because Ohio law makes the location of casting an express condition" 1. It argues that LaRose's Directive 2026-35 is only an administrative instruction and cannot expand where provisional ballots may be cast 5. Taft did not respond to requests for comment, and neither did LaRose's office 12.
Why the timing matters
Democrats flipped at least eight Ohio House seats on Nov. 3, which ended the Republican supermajority, the two-thirds share that lets one party pass some measures without the other 12. Three more state House races were still too close to call as of Wednesday 1. Unofficial results show 102,148 provisional ballots were cast across Ohio 2.
Ockerman warned that counties could end up using different rules. Courts have said that must not happen across Ohio's 88 counties, and at least two counties have already certified their results 2. Jen Miller of the League of Women Voters objected to "changing the rules after Election Day is over and throwing out valid ballots" 2.
The pattern is familiar. Democracy Docket reports that Republicans made similar demands about ballots in Mississippi's Senate race earlier this month 1. The approach is to wait until the votes are in, then challenge whole categories of ballots in the races that are closest.
That matters to older voters in particular. Many Ohioans move to another county late in life, whether to be near grandchildren, to downsize or to move into senior housing, and updating a voter registration can slip through the cracks. Those voters did what poll workers and the state's top election official told them to do. Whether their ballots count now depends largely on how LaRose decides the tie votes.
The Record
- Ohio holds its general election. Democrats flip at least eight Ohio House seats and end the Republican supermajority 12.
- Taft Stettinius & Hollister files a four-page objection with the Lucas County board for Republican candidate Edward Schimmel, asking it to reject provisional ballots from voters who moved within Ohio 4.
- The Lucas County board approves 835 early vote center and 1,540 Election Day provisional ballots after a closed-door session 4.
- The League of Women Voters of Ohio and the ACLU of Ohio write to all 88 county boards urging them to count the ballots 6. Hamilton County's board deadlocks, sending the decision to LaRose 3.
Republish this story on your site or in your newsletter
Any site, blog or newsletter may run this story free of charge. Keep the credit line and its link to the original, do not sell it, and edit only for length or house style (the full terms). Photos carry their own licenses, noted under each photo on this page, so use the text alone unless a credit says otherwise.
Paste it into your editor's HTML view. The one-pixel image at the end tells our newsroom the story ran; it stores no reader data.
Sources
- Democracy Docket, “Republicans challenge thousands of Ohio ballots, voting groups say” (2026-11-18). democracydocket.com/news-alerts/republicans-challenge-thousa
- Statehouse News Bureau, “ACLU says law firm has raised questions about some provisional ballots in Ohio” (2026-11-17). statenews.org/government-politics/2026-11-17/aclu-says-law-f
- WLWT, “Law firm contesting some provisional ballots in 6 Ohio counties, including Hamilton” (2026-11-17). wlwt.com/article/hamilton-county-law-firm-elections-provisio
- WTOL 11, “Lucas County Board of Elections approves thousands of provisional ballots, rejects hundreds after closed-door legal session” (2026-11-16). yahoo.com/news/politics/articles/lucas-county-board-election
- WTOL 11, “Voting rights groups write to boards of elections, urge provisional vote count responding to prior partisan law firm letter” (2026-11-17). yahoo.com/news/politics/articles/voting-rights-groups-write-
- ACLU of Ohio, “League of Women Voters of Ohio and ACLU of Ohio Send Letter to County Boards of Elections to Ensure Provisional Votes Are Counted in Accordance With Existing SOS Directive” (2026-11-17). acluohio.org/press-releases/league-of-women-voters-of-ohio-a
Found an error? Tell the newsroom. Corrections are noted at the top of the story.
More from the files
Outgoing Ohio elections chief LaRose seeks power to audit voter rolls as state auditor
Frank LaRose, a Republican, has run Ohio's voter rolls since 2019. He now wants the auditor's office he takes over in January to inspect the rolls, after a Democrat won his old job. Secretary of State-elect Allison Russo calls the idea an attempt to politicize who stays on the rolls.
Ohio's incoming Democratic elections chief plans to ease GOP voting limits where she can
Allison Russo, who flipped Ohio's top election office on Nov. 3, says she will review her Republican predecessor's rules and use her power over early voting hours. Voters also wrote strict photo ID into the state constitution the same night, and she can't undo that.
Democratic wave voters still wrote voter ID into three state constitutions
Democrats won big on Nov. 3, but voters in Nevada, Ohio and North Carolina approved voter ID amendments. Voters in California, Colorado and Arizona turned similar measures down. Once a rule is in a state constitution, it is much harder for lawmakers to change it.
Delivered free to your door*
The Morning Edition
One short email at 7 a.m. Eastern: the day's top files, one clip worth your time, and the race to watch. Plain English, large type, no clutter.
*Your inbox. Free. Unsubscribe with one click, any time.






