Rights & Freedoms · Report · File No. 261118-307
Miami-Dade voter sues DeSantis over state Senate seat left empty for 84 days
The ACLU of Florida asked the state Supreme Court on Nov. 17 to order Gov. Ron DeSantis to call a special election for a Senate seat representing about half a million people. It is the seventh lawsuit since 2021 meant to make him fill an empty seat.
Every quote in this story (4) was matched word for word against its source. How we work

On Tuesday, Nov. 17, a voter in Doral, Florida, asked the Florida Supreme Court to order Gov. Ron DeSantis to call a special election for a state Senate seat. The seat has been empty since late August 12. The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) of Florida filed the petition for the voter, Alejandro Peñuela 1.
State Senate District 39 covers Hialeah, Doral, Sweetwater and Miami Lakes in northwest Miami-Dade County 1. According to the ACLU, the district's roughly half a million residents have now gone 84 days without a state senator 14.
The seat opened when Republican Sen. Bryan Ávila resigned, effective Aug. 25, to run for lieutenant governor on Byron Donalds' ticket 3. Donalds won the Nov. 3 governor's race with 50.3% of the vote to Democrat David Jolly's 48.8%, according to an Associated Press projection 9.
Doral and Hialeah deserve a state senator to be our voice in Tallahassee without delay.
What the lawsuit asks
The filing asks for a writ of mandamus, which is a court order telling a public official to do something the law requires 3. It argues that Florida law requires the governor to set the dates of special elections, so he has no choice in the matter. The petition says DeSantis has a clear legal duty to do so 3.
From Channel GOPDeSantis says Bondi's Epstein files promise fell apartGov. Ron DeSantis · 3K plays · captioned, with the source named
The petition asks for an election "as soon as possible" but does not suggest dates 3. The governor's office had not answered a request for comment, and none of the coverage reviewed for this story included a response from DeSantis or his staff 23.
The timing matters. The Legislature's interim committee meetings start Nov. 30, and the regular session opens March 2, 2027 3. The suit says the vacancy leaves district residents without representation for both 4.
The ACLU also points to cost. It says that if DeSantis had acted soon after Ávila resigned, a special primary or general election could have been held alongside city elections already set for late November or December. A separate election will likely cost taxpayers more 14.
A pattern, the ACLU says
This is the seventh lawsuit since 2021 in which voters have gone to court to make DeSantis schedule a special election 12. Earlier suits covered nine empty legislative or congressional seats in Tampa, Palm Beach, Northwest Florida, and Brevard, Miami-Dade and Broward counties 1. Each time, DeSantis set an election only after the suit was filed 2.
The first case came in 2021, after the death of Democratic U.S. Rep. Alcee Hastings, whose South Florida congressional district was heavily Democratic. DeSantis set the election date nine months after Hastings died 5. In 2023, the ACLU sued over a Miami-Dade state House seat, and within days he set a date 5. In January 2025 it sued again, over a Brevard County Senate seat and a Panhandle House seat 56.
The ACLU says earlier governors usually called special elections within a week of a resignation, often in under five days 1. Nicholas Warren, a senior staff attorney with the group, said governors including Jeb Bush and Rick Scott "consistently acted quickly" to keep Floridians represented 4.
There is no good reason for this governor to keep resisting timely special elections.
Warren called DeSantis's refusal "as perplexing as it is illegal" 4. The group's lawyers describe the string of lawsuits as "a disturbing pattern that both undermines our republican form of government and wastes judicial resources" 4. These are claims in a lawsuit, and the court has not ruled.
What the governor's side has said
In the coverage reviewed, the governor's office has not explained the delays. In January 2025, when reporters asked about an earlier ACLU suit, his office sent them to the Florida Department of State 5. A department spokesman said at the time that it "continues to work with the Supervisors of Elections to identify suitable dates for special elections" 6.
Congressional seats got faster treatment. After Republicans Matt Gaetz and Mike Waltz resigned from Congress, DeSantis quickly set special elections for their seats, with a Jan. 28 primary and an April 1 general election. When the ACLU sued in January 2025, he still had not set dates for the two empty state seats 5. Secretary of State Cord Byrd, a DeSantis appointee, described the congressional elections this way 6:
At Governor Ron DeSantis' direction, this Special Election is being conducted as quickly as statutorily possible
A fix that died in Tallahassee
Democrats tried to put deadlines into law. Senate Bill 460, sponsored by Sen. Tina Polsky, a Democrat from Broward and Palm Beach counties, had a House twin, House Bill 597, from Democratic Rep. Michael Gottlieb. In most cases the bills would have given the governor 14 days to set election dates. If he did not, voters could have asked a circuit judge to set them 7.
Two Senate committees approved the bill unanimously, 8-0 on Feb. 4 and 11-0 on Feb. 10. It then died in the Senate Rules Committee on March 13, 2026, without a vote by the full Senate 8.
It shouldn't be dependent on politics or what the seat looks like
Before the session, Polsky said the bill would be hard to pass, "especially because the person who has to sign the bill is the one who caused these problems" 7. In the new lawsuit, the ACLU's policy director, Kara Gross, urged the Legislature to "enact mandatory deadlines for calling and holding special elections" 1.
That matters because this fight is not about which party gains. District 39 is a Republican seat that Ávila won by nearly 40 percentage points in 2024 4. The real question is whether Florida voters can count on getting a lawmaker back quickly when a seat opens. Right now the governor decides when that happens, the bill to set deadlines never reached a floor vote, and the courts have become the backstop.
The Record
- The ACLU of Florida sues DeSantis over unscheduled special elections for a Brevard County Senate seat and a Panhandle House seat 6.
- Senate Bill 460, which would have required special election dates within 14 days in most cases, dies in the Senate Rules Committee 8.
- Republican state Sen. Bryan Ávila's resignation takes effect so he can run for lieutenant governor, leaving District 39 empty 13.
- Byron Donalds, with Ávila as his running mate, is projected to win Florida's governor's race 9.
- The ACLU of Florida files Peñuela v. DeSantis in the Florida Supreme Court, the seventh such suit since 2021 1.
Republish this story on your site or in your newsletter
Any site, blog or newsletter may run this story free of charge. Keep the credit line and its link to the original, do not sell it, and edit only for length or house style (the full terms). Photos carry their own licenses, noted under each photo on this page, so use the text alone unless a credit says otherwise.
Paste it into your editor's HTML view. The one-pixel image at the end tells our newsroom the story ran; it stores no reader data.
Sources
- ACLU of Florida, “Florida Voter Sues Governor DeSantis in the Florida Supreme Court for Failing to Call Special Election for Vacant State Senate Seat” (2026-11-17). aclufl.org/press-releases/florida-voter-sues-governor-desant
- WLRN, “Miami-Dade voter sues Gov. DeSantis for failing to call a special election” (2026-11-17). wlrn.org/government-politics/2026-11-17/doral-florida-voter-
- Yahoo News, “DeSantis sued over vacant Florida Senate seat once held by Bryan Avila” (2026-11-17). yahoo.com/news/politics/articles/desantis-sued-over-vacant-f
- Florida Phoenix via Creative Loafing Tampa, “DeSantis sued (again) to fulfill constitutional duty and hold special election for vacant Florida Senate seat” (2026-11-17). cltampa.com/news/desantis-sued-again-to-fulfill-constitution
- WLRN, “ACLU sues DeSantis for not calling special elections for state House and Senate seats” (2025-01-10). wlrn.org/law-justice/2025-01-10/aclu-sues-desantis-for-not-c
- Yahoo News, “ACLU of Florida sues Gov. DeSantis over special election delays for legislative seats” (2025-01-09). yahoo.com/news/aclu-florida-sues-gov-desantis-212110338.html
- South Florida Sun Sentinel via Yahoo News, “Lawmakers seek to end approach Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis has used in delaying special elections” (2025-12-23). yahoo.com/news/articles/lawmakers-seek-end-approach-florida-
- LegiList, “Florida SB 460 (2026): Special Elections” (2026-03-13). legilist.com/states/florida/bill/2026/sb-460
- WWSB / Associated Press, “AP projects Byron Donalds' history-making victory as the next Florida governor” (2026-11-04). mysuncoast.com/2026/11/04/ap-projects-byron-donalds-history-
Found an error? Tell the newsroom. Corrections are noted at the top of the story.
More from the files
Exonerees urge Gov.-elect Donalds to pause executions as Florida nears record 20th
Three men once sentenced to death in Florida asked Byron Donalds to halt executions. His office says he will not, and the state's 20th execution of 2026 is set for next week.
Gov.-elect Donalds makes Florida property tax overhaul his first priority
Florida voters approved Amendment 3 on Nov. 3, and Republican Byron Donalds says more property tax changes are coming. Experts warn local budgets could take a hit, which could mean fewer services or higher fees.
Muslim civil rights group CAIR shuts down in Florida as state terror label takes effect
A federal judge refused to block Florida from labeling the Council on American-Islamic Relations a terrorist group, so its Florida chapter closed on Thursday. The law lets five state officials put that label on a U.S. nonprofit without criminal charges or a trial, and the ACLU says it will appeal.
Delivered free to your door*
The Morning Edition
One short email at 7 a.m. Eastern: the day's top files, one clip worth your time, and the race to watch. Plain English, large type, no clutter.
*Your inbox. Free. Unsubscribe with one click, any time.






