Voting Rights · Report · File No. 261115-923
Election experts urge appeals court to end Trump DOJ suit over Alaska Senate count
A former Arizona election official and a team of election law scholars filed friend-of-the-court briefs Friday. They want the Ninth Circuit to stop the Justice Department's attempt to hold up certification of Alaska's Senate race, where Democrat Mary Peltola leads. The case tests whether Washington can step into a state's vote count after the ballots are cast.
Every quote in this story (5) was matched word for word against its source. How we work

A former election chief from Arizona and a group of election law scholars told a federal appeals court Friday to throw out the Trump administration's lawsuit over Alaska's U.S. Senate race. Both filed amicus briefs, the friend-of-the-court arguments that people who are not parties to a case can submit, with the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals 1.
One brief came from Stephen Richer, the former recorder of Maricopa County, Ariz. The other came from the Safeguarding Democracy Project at UCLA School of Law, which is led by election law professor Richard Hasen 1.
The Justice Department sued to block Alaska from certifying the Senate race if the Republican incumbent, Sen. Dan Sullivan, lost. Its argument is that a longshot candidate with a similar name, Dan J. Sullivan, confused voters 1. A district judge threw out the suit on Nov. 1, and the department went straight to the appeals court 1.
There is no basis for the federal government to challenge that result—or for a federal court to circumvent it.
How the lawsuit started
The department filed the case on Oct. 22, and President Trump said he ordered it 3. The department calls the second candidate "Decoy Dan" and says he was recruited to confuse voters. It asked for an investigation into what voters meant to do 3. Peltola's campaign and the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee (DSCC), the party's Senate campaign arm, deny any role in recruiting him 3.
From Channel GOPPeltola: Tariffs doubled Alaska air taxi's parts billMary Peltola · 142 plays · captioned, with the source named
So we have two Dan Sullivans. This is voter fraud at the highest level.
On Nov. 1, two days before Election Day, U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason dismissed the case in Anchorage 3. She found the government had not shown that the court could actually fix the harm it claimed. Courts call that redressability, and without it a plaintiff has no standing to sue 3. She also found that letting the government amend its complaint again "would be futile" 3. She did not decide whether the second Sullivan was recruited 3.
Gleason wrote that the department offered no workable plan for separating the ballots in question 2. Setting ballots aside for law enforcement review, she said, was not a remedy the court could or should order 4. A Justice Department spokesperson said the court dismissed the case on procedural grounds and added: "Alaskan voters deserve a fair election, not to be misled in an attempt to rig outcomes." 3
Today's ruling is a victory for democracy and a clear message to Donald Trump and Senate Republicans
What the new briefs argue
Richer argues that Alaska already settled the two-Sullivans question in its own courts before the election. A state trial court ruled that the other Sullivan could stay on the ballot, and the Alaska Supreme Court agreed 1. He notes that the ballot identified Sen. Sullivan as the incumbent Republican. He argues that complaints like this belong at the ballot-access stage, before anyone votes 1. "The machinery of state election law operated as designed," his brief says 1.
The Hasen group's brief says the case should be thrown out under laches, a rule that bars claims brought too late, because the department waited too long to sue 1. It argues that the state alone should certify its results 1.
Leading election law experts from across the political spectrum uniformly derided this lawsuit filed by the United States
The briefs back a Nov. 9 request from the League of Women Voters of Alaska and Common Cause, which have joined the case to defend the election. Those groups asked the appeals court to uphold the dismissal without full briefing. They also want Justice Department lawyers ordered to explain why they should not be sanctioned for a frivolous appeal 2. The groups called the government's legal theory "embarrassing and indefensible" and said its demands would violate the secret ballot 2.
The count and the calendar
The ballots point the other way from the lawsuit. In the latest tally reported by the Anchorage Daily News, Peltola had 50.1% of first-choice votes to Sen. Sullivan's 46.1%. Dan J. Sullivan had 1.7% and Republican Gerald Heikes had 2.1%, with more than 283,000 ballots counted 5. That puts Peltola ahead of both Sullivans combined 1. Counting continues through Wednesday, the last day Alaska accepts absentee ballots mailed from overseas 5.
The appeals schedule is slow. The Justice Department's opening brief is not due until Dec. 14, and answering briefs are due Jan. 11, 2027 4. Alaska's target date for certifying the result is Nov. 25 4. As of Friday, the department had not filed a brief setting out its legal argument 1.
The governor's role is also in question. Gov. Mike Dunleavy, a Republican, has refused to commit to signing off on certification if Peltola wins 6. In an interview last month he said, "If we conclude there were things… that are illegal, we will act on that." 6 He added that this "may in fact impact whether somebody is seated in the U.S. Senate." 6 Alaska's next governor takes office Dec. 7 6. The conservative site Alaska Story reported that a separate criminal investigation is still going 7.
Sen. Sullivan has made the same charge as the White House. In a CNN interview he said of his opponents: "Recognizing they couldn't run on their record, so they had to cheat," 3. No court has found that anyone broke the law.
That matters because the department did not ask for a recount or report a counting error. Before the election, it asked a federal court to hold up a state's result and look into how individual voters marked their ballots 32. Neither the trial judge nor the state courts accepted that theory 31. Disclosure on sources: Democracy Docket, which reported on the briefs, was founded by Marc Elias. His law firm represents the Peltola campaign and the DSCC in this case 26.
The Record
- The Justice Department sues to delay certification of Alaska's Senate race if Sen. Dan Sullivan loses. President Trump says he ordered the suit 3.
- U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason dismisses the suit for lack of standing, and the department says it will appeal to the Ninth Circuit 3.
- The League of Women Voters of Alaska and Common Cause ask the Ninth Circuit to affirm the dismissal quickly and to consider sanctions against government lawyers 2.
- Stephen Richer and UCLA's Safeguarding Democracy Project file amicus briefs urging the appeals court to end the suit 1.
- Target date for Alaska to certify the election. The department's opening appeals brief is not due until Dec. 14 4.
Republish this story on your site or in your newsletter
Any site, blog or newsletter may run this story free of charge. Keep the credit line and its link to the original, do not sell it, and edit only for length or house style (the full terms). Photos carry their own licenses, noted under each photo on this page, so use the text alone unless a credit says otherwise.
Paste it into your editor's HTML view. The one-pixel image at the end tells our newsroom the story ran; it stores no reader data.
Sources
- Democracy Docket, “Reject Trump's 'embarrassing' Alaska lawsuit, voting experts tell court” (2026-11-14). democracydocket.com/news-alerts/reject-trumps-embarrassing-a
- Democracy Docket, “'Embarrassing and indefensible': Trump's Alaska appeal should be dismissed ASAP, voting advocates say” (2026-11-09). democracydocket.com/news-alerts/embarrassing-and-indefensibl
- CNBC, “Alaska Senate: Judge dismisses DOJ lawsuit over Sullivan names” (2026-11-01). cnbc.com/2026/11/01/alaska-senate-doj-lawsuit-dismissed-sull
- Newsweek (via Yahoo News), “The Lawsuit Over Two Dan Sullivans May Not Be Over Yet” (2026-11-05). yahoo.com/news/politics/articles/lawsuit-over-two-dan-sulliv
- Anchorage Daily News, “Peltola now has majority of votes in Alaska's U.S. Senate race as ballot counting continues” (2026-11-14). adn.com/politics/2026/11/13/peltola-grows-lead-in-alaskas-us
- Democracy Docket, “Democrat wins Alaska governor race, in setback for GOP scheme to steal Senate seat” (2026-11-13). democracydocket.com/news-alerts/democrat-wins-alaska-governo
- Alaska Story, “Ninth Circuit reverses course on DOJ ballot demands as Alaska fights its own election case” (2026-11-03). thealaskastory.com/ninth-circuit-reverses-course-on-doj-ball
Found an error? Tell the newsroom. Corrections are noted at the top of the story.
More from the files
Alaska Senate race stays uncalled as DOJ appeal and ballot count run on parallel tracks
Democrat Mary Peltola leads Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan by a few hundred votes with about 74% counted, and the Justice Department is appealing a dismissed lawsuit over a same-named candidate on the ballot. The outcome will decide whether that legal fight still matters.
Judge tosses Trump administration suit to block Alaska Senate results if Sullivan loses
A federal judge ruled the Justice Department cannot bring its suit over Alaska's Senate race. The ruling comes two days before the midterms, and the department is expected to appeal.
Justice Department asks judge to set aside Alaska ballots that rank Dan J. Sullivan
The filing, five days before the midterm election, asks that ballots ranking the second Dan Sullivan be preserved and kept separate while the government investigates whether voters were confused. Alaska's governor has already ordered a state investigation into Mary Peltola's campaign.
Delivered free to your door*
The Morning Edition
One short email at 7 a.m. Eastern: the day's top files, one clip worth your time, and the race to watch. Plain English, large type, no clutter.
*Your inbox. Free. Unsubscribe with one click, any time.






