Saturday, November 21, 2026 Vol. I · No. 31 · Morning Edition Print size
Paper
Election 2026 503 of 506 races called See the results → The GOP Files Receipts on the Republican-run Washington · Sourced · Dated · On the record On Instagram 7.7M plays and counting @thegopfiles →
The Wire
Medicare proposes first mandatory Medicare Advantage test and tougher plan ratings On tape: Elizabeth Warren gets Betsy DeVos to admit she never ran a bank or a federal student loan program On tape: Trump's former lawyer won't say if Trump can defy a Supreme Court order when Peter Welch asks him Nasdaq erases 2026 gains as S&P 500 and Dow fall into correction on AI selloff On tape: Trump won't say Putin is America's friend: "I can't speak to America" On tape: Warnock presses Scott Bessent with St. Trump says Iowa gas was $1.85 before the Iran war. AAA records show $2.63 Liverpool, N.Y., superintendent apologizes after walkout over LGBTQ+ student policy Texas grand jury indicts 21 in racketeering case against La Nueva Familia Michoacana Virginia child dies after measles diagnosis, state's first measles death of 2026 Medicare proposes first mandatory Medicare Advantage test and tougher plan ratings On tape: Elizabeth Warren gets Betsy DeVos to admit she never ran a bank or a federal student loan program On tape: Trump's former lawyer won't say if Trump can defy a Supreme Court order when Peter Welch asks him Nasdaq erases 2026 gains as S&P 500 and Dow fall into correction on AI selloff On tape: Trump won't say Putin is America's friend: "I can't speak to America" On tape: Warnock presses Scott Bessent with St. Trump says Iowa gas was $1.85 before the Iran war. AAA records show $2.63 Liverpool, N.Y., superintendent apologizes after walkout over LGBTQ+ student policy Texas grand jury indicts 21 in racketeering case against La Nueva Familia Michoacana Virginia child dies after measles diagnosis, state's first measles death of 2026

Social Security & Medicare · Report · File No. 261121-264

Medicare proposes first mandatory Medicare Advantage test and tougher plan ratings

On Nov. 20, the Trump administration's Medicare agency proposed rules for 2028 that would change how private Medicare plans are rated and paid, and how much they can charge for ambulance rides. Four days earlier it had proposed tougher billing audits of the same insurers. Democrats have long said the plans are overpaid, and the question is whether the new proposals will hold insurers to account.

Every quote in this story (4) was matched word for word against its source. How we work

My clippings
Mehmet Oz
Mehmet Oz. Photo: Philip Cohen, CC BY-SA 4.0

On Thursday, Nov. 20, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), the federal agency that runs Medicare, proposed a long list of changes for 2028 to Medicare Advantage and to Part D, the drug coverage program 12. Medicare Advantage plans are run by private insurers such as UnitedHealthcare and Humana. People can pick one of these plans instead of traditional Medicare.

The proposal would make the plans' star ratings harder to earn. It would also put a dollar limit on what plans can charge for a ground ambulance ride. And it would set up the first Medicare Advantage experiment that insurers would be required to join 12. Nothing has been decided yet. The public can comment for 60 days after the rule is published in the Federal Register 1.

This is the agency's second rule for 2028. The first came out on Oct. 16, 2026 2.

Mehmet Oz
These proposals are about creating a Medicare Advantage marketplace that rewards better care and better value
Mehmet Oz, Administrator, Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services1

Fewer measures, a higher bar for bonuses

Medicare grades each private plan from one to five stars. Plans with high scores get extra federal money called quality bonus payments. CMS wants to cut the list of things it grades down to 15 measures, with the focus on health results and patients' experiences 1. The agency says the new math would "raise the bar" for top ratings and for the bonuses that come with them 12.

From Channel GOPWarren gets DeVos to admit no loan experienceElizabeth Warren · captioned, with the source named

Some of the proposed changes would take effect with the 2028 measurement period and show up in the 2030 star ratings. Others include dropping a "reward factor" that currently helps some plans' scores 2. The CMS documents we reviewed do not say how much bonus money plans might lose 23.

That matters because Democrats have argued the rating system already goes easy on insurers. In an April 2 letter to CMS chief Mehmet Oz, Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) and seven other senators objected to an earlier CMS plan to drop measures that track complaints about prior authorization. Prior authorization means a plan must approve care before you get it 7. The letter said Medicare Advantage insurers fully or partly denied about 4.1 million such requests in 2024. That is more than 27 times the number of denials in traditional Medicare 7.

Elizabeth Warren
legitimate fraud, waste, and abuse in Medicare Advantage remains largely unchecked.
Elizabeth Warren, U.S. senator, D-Mass., in a letter with seven other senators7

What could change for patients

Some proposals would affect members directly. CMS says today's limits on what plans charge for emergency care still "rely on 2021 figures." It would update the limit to between $180 and $240, depending on the plan's yearly out-of-pocket maximum 2.

CMS says it has never set a dollar cap for ground ambulance rides. Under the proposal, plans could charge no more than 30% to 50% of Medicare's average cost, which works out to a limit of $180 to $300 2. The $300 top figure matches the 50% coinsurance standard that lower-cost plans already follow 2.

One change would add a step for some people. Today, people hit by a declared disaster can get a special window to change plans. Under the proposal, they would first need approval through 1-800-MEDICARE. CMS says data suggest plans may be misusing that window, including to sign up people who were not affected by a disaster 2.

Many plans offer grocery or produce benefits. Those would have to meet a new "healthy food" standard based on the 2025-2030 Dietary Guidelines for Americans. Items a doctor recommends for a patient's medical needs would still be covered 12. CMS says the produce benefit for chronically ill members was used nearly 40 million times in 2025 1.

Robert F. Kennedy Jr.
Medicare food benefits should pay for nutritious food that helps people improve their health and manage chronic disease,
Robert F. Kennedy Jr., Secretary of Health and Human Services1

A required test in states not yet named

The largest new idea is a 10-year experiment called ADVaNCE MA. It would start on Jan. 1, 2029, and a preparation period would begin June 8, 2027 3. In states chosen at random, every insurer with an eligible plan would have to take part. The states would be named only in the final rule 23.

In those states, a new system called "Diamond Ratings" would replace the star ratings and the bonus payments tied to them 3. Plans could also aim certain extra benefits, such as food, rides to appointments and caregiver help, at people who qualify for Extra Help. Extra Help is the federal program that lowers drug costs for people with limited incomes 3. CMS says a new payment formula would be tested only on paper for now and would not affect plan payments or members 3.

Lloyd Doggett
Despite their early claims of greater efficiency and lower costs, Medicare Advantage has never saved a penny.
Lloyd Doggett, U.S. representative, D-Texas, ranking member of the Ways and Means health subcommittee8

The audit fight four days earlier

The Nov. 20 proposal followed a separate CMS plan, announced Nov. 16, to step up billing audits of Medicare Advantage insurers 5. These audits check whether plans claimed patients were sicker than they were, which brings in higher payments. CMS would apply what it finds in sample audits to whole contracts, starting with payment year 2018. It says this would recover about $9 billion per payment year on average 5.

Investors reacted fast. On Nov. 18, UnitedHealth stock fell 10.2% and Humana fell 12.7% 6. A federal court threw out the agency's 2023 audit rule in September 2025, and some analysts expect the new plan to face court challenges too 6. Comments on the audit proposal are due Jan. 19, 2027 45. CMS's estimate of nearly $90 billion in total savings has not been reviewed by the agency's actuary, the expert who checks its cost numbers 4.

Our analysis: these proposals tighten some rules on insurers, but they come from an agency that Democrats say has gone easy on the industry. In July, Rep. Lloyd Doggett (D-Texas) and 44 colleagues introduced the Saving MEDICARE Act. It would end the quality bonus program entirely and crack down on plans that inflate patients' diagnoses 8. His release cited an estimate that Medicare Advantage will cost $2,660 more per enrollee in 2026 than traditional Medicare 8. Democrats will control Congress in January, so they will be in a position to push that bill and to watch how these rules are finalized.

The Record

  1. Warren and seven other senators urge Oz to crack down on Medicare Advantage overpayments and prior authorization denials 7
  2. Doggett and 44 Democrats introduce the Saving MEDICARE Act to end Medicare Advantage bonus payments and curb inflated diagnoses 8
  3. HHS announces a proposed anti-fraud rule that would expand Medicare Advantage billing audits back to 2018 5
  4. UnitedHealth shares fall 10.2% and Humana 12.7% as investors weigh the audit proposal 6
  5. CMS proposes 2028 Medicare Advantage changes, including tougher star ratings and the mandatory ADVaNCE MA model 12
Republish this story on your site or in your newsletter

Any site, blog or newsletter may run this story free of charge. Keep the credit line and its link to the original, do not sell it, and edit only for length or house style (the full terms). Photos carry their own licenses, noted under each photo on this page, so use the text alone unless a credit says otherwise.

Paste it into your editor's HTML view. The one-pixel image at the end tells our newsroom the story ran; it stores no reader data.

Sources

  1. CMS, “CMS Proposes Reforms to Strengthen Competition, Elevate Care Quality, and Expand Beneficiary Choice in Medicare Advantage” (2026-11-20). cms.gov/newsroom/press-releases/cms-proposes-reforms-strengt
  2. CMS, “Contract Year 2028 Policy and Technical Changes to the Medicare Advantage Program, Medicare Prescription Drug Benefit Program, and Medicare Cost Plan Program (CMS-4214-P2) fact sheet” (2026-11-20). cms.gov/newsroom/fact-sheets/contract-year-2028-policy-techn
  3. CMS Innovation Center, “ADVaNCE MA (Aligning Data and Value to Nurture Competition and Efficiency in Medicare Advantage) Model” (2026-11-20). cms.gov/initiatives/innovation-center/advance-ma
  4. HFMA, “CMS's CRUSH proposed rule would increase fraud oversight across federal programs” (2026-11-17). hfma.org/legal-and-regulatory-compliance/cms-crush-proposed-
  5. Medical Daily, “CMS CRUSH Rule Would Expand Medicare Advantage Audits and Curb Supplier Texts, With Nearly $90 Billion Projected Savings” (2026-11-17). medicaldaily.com/cms-crush-rule-medicare-advantage-audits-48
  6. Beinsure, “Healthcare stocks (UnitedHealth, Humana, CVS, Cigna) fall on new Medicare rules” (2026-11-18). beinsure.com/news/healthcare-stocks-fall-as-medicare-rules-t
  7. Office of Sen. Elizabeth Warren, “Warren, Senators Push Dr. Oz to Tackle Medicare Advantage Abuse” (2026-04-02). warren.senate.gov/newsroom/press-releases/warren-senators-pu
  8. Office of Rep. Lloyd Doggett, “Democrats Introduce Saving MEDICARE Act to Stop Insurers' Profiteering Off Medicare” (2026-07-01). doggett.house.gov/media/press-releases/democrats-introduce-s

Found an error? Tell the newsroom. Corrections are noted at the top of the story.

More from the files

Delivered free to your door*

The Morning Edition

One short email at 7 a.m. Eastern: the day's top files, one clip worth your time, and the race to watch. Plain English, large type, no clutter.

*Your inbox. Free. Unsubscribe with one click, any time.