At a Senate Judiciary Committee nomination hearing, Sen. Dick Durbin asked the nominee about his argument that an officer had probable cause to arrest a 10-year-old under Mississippi's indecent exposure statute for urinating in public. The court rejected it, saying a 10-year-old cannot have the required state of mind. Asked to comment, the nominee said his cases "only tell half the story" of his career.
The receipt
- Who
- Sen. Dick Durbin
- Where
- hearing - Senate Judiciary Committee, nomination of G. Todd Butler to the Fifth
- Original footage
- Forbes Breaking News · watch the full video from this moment
- Length
- 50 seconds, unedited within the cut
- Plays
- 367 on Instagram
Read the transcript
An officer arrested a 10 -year -old child. He argued that the officer had probable cause that this child violated the Mississippi indecent exposure statute for urinating in public. Thankfully the court rejected your argument because a 10 -year -old they believe cannot have of requisite state of mind to violate a statute. Would you like to comment on that defense? Thank you, Senator. I have defended a number of difficult 1983 cases over the years. Many of the cases do have difficult facts, but what I would say any of my work, any of my cases as an advocate only tell half the story of my career.
Machine transcript of the clip's audio; names are checked, small words may differ.