Climate & Disasters · Report · File No. 261118-410
EPA hears testimony on plan to weaken oil and gas methane leak rules; comments due Dec. 16
The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) held two days of virtual hearings on a Trump administration plan to weaken limits on methane leaks from oil and gas wells. The agency's own numbers show more smog-forming pollution, and it put no dollar figure on the harm to health.
Every quote in this story (3) was matched word for word against its source. How we work

The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) held virtual public hearings Monday and Tuesday, Nov. 16 and 17, on a Trump administration plan to roll back limits on methane from oil and gas operations 210. Methane is a gas that warms the planet and leaks from wells, pipelines and equipment 1.
The plan would end a program that tracks very large leaks. It would also lift a ban on routine flaring at oil wells and exempt many older, low-producing wells from leak checks 17. The public can still weigh in: written comments are due Dec. 16, 2026, under docket number EPA-HQ-OAR-2025-0163 on regulations.gov 2.
What the EPA wants to change
The rules being targeted were published March 8, 2024, under President Biden 2. They require oil and gas companies to find and fix leaks and to stop routinely flaring, or burning off, gas at oil wells. They also created a Super Emitter Program that lets outside monitoring data flag giant releases 17.
EPA Administrator Lee Zeldin previewed the rollback Oct. 7 at the New Mexico Oil and Gas Association's conference in Santa Fe. He called the Super Emitter Program "not necessary" and "not effective" 3. The agency formally proposed the changes Oct. 27, and they were published in the Federal Register, the government's official journal of rules, on Oct. 29 27.
From Channel GOPSchiff reads State Department cable on Musk's Starlink dealSen. Adam Schiff · 280 plays · captioned, with the source named
Under the proposal, oil wells would no longer have to send their leftover gas to market. Most wells could burn it in a device that destroys 95% of the pollution instead 7. Wells producing 15 barrels of oil equivalent a day or less could be put in a separate "marginal" category with weaker standards 7.
Americans must be able to afford to heat their homes in the winter and fill up their car and drive to work
The EPA says the package would provide about $45 billion in economic benefits from 2027 to 2050. That total combines $42 billion in lower compliance costs with $3 billion in energy market savings 7. The agency also projects about 210 million more barrels of oil and 1.41 trillion more cubic feet of natural gas 7.
The pollution the EPA's own analysis expects
The agency's own analysis also counts the downside. From 2027 through 2050, it estimates about 60 million more short tons of methane and about 17 million more tons of volatile organic compounds, which help form smog. It also expects about 2.3 million more tons of hazardous air pollutants 6. Under an alternative version the EPA is also considering, methane could rise by 88 million short tons 7.
The EPA did not put a dollar value on the health effects. It listed harm from the added ozone and air toxics as unquantified 6. That matters because those effects fall on real neighborhoods. About 1 million Pennsylvanians live within half a mile of oil and gas operations, according to an Environmental Defense Fund expert cited by Medical Daily 6. In Maine, about 1 in 9 residents has asthma, compared with 1 in 12 nationally 9.
Over 20 years, methane has more than 80 times the warming power of carbon dioxide. It has driven about one-third of the warming so far 1. The low-producing wells the plan would go easier on account for nearly half of the industry's methane emissions 1. By the Environmental Defense Fund's count, they supply less than 5% of the nation's oil and gas 8.
What people told the EPA
Public health experts, environmental groups and residents of drilling regions testified against the plan, the Sierra Club said 1. Sierra Club organizer Antoinette Reyes, who works in the Permian Basin oil fields of Texas and New Mexico, warned that "State action alone cannot fill the gap left by federal rollbacks" 1. Speaking for Pennsylvania, one of the leading states for fracked gas infrastructure, Sarah Corcoran pointed to the state's high rates of childhood asthma and cancer 1.
We need stronger protections in place for methane, not looser.
The Environmental Defense Fund, an advocacy group, says nearly $7 billion worth of natural gas has been leaked, vented or flared since March 12, 2025. That is the date the group says the administration stopped enforcing the methane rules 8. "EPA should not give oil and gas companies more room to waste a domestic resource," said the group's Jon Goldstein 8.
Democratic states vow to hold the line
New Mexico ranks second in U.S. crude oil production and third in natural gas, and its Democratic leaders pushed back right away 3. Sen. Ben Ray Luján said "New Mexico has shown that strong methane protections can support our energy industry while protecting public health" 3. The state is also weighing a tougher rule of its own, with a hearing set for Dec. 1 3.
In New Mexico, we won't stand for that. Our methane rules will remain firmly in place
Zeldin has acknowledged the legal risk himself. In Santa Fe, he said the EPA has a "core statutory obligation" to regulate these pollutants. He warned that a decision that does not meet the Clean Air Act's requirements "will be overturned in court" 3. The Sierra Club's senior attorney, Andres Restrepo, said the group "will use every resource at its disposal to fight back" 1.
The agency counts the industry's savings in dollars but leaves the health costs unpriced 67. For now, the 2024 rule stays in effect, and its requirements do not change until a final rule replaces it 7.
The Record
- EPA publishes the Biden-era methane rule for new and existing oil and gas sources 2
- The Environmental Defense Fund says the administration stopped enforcing oil and gas methane rules on this date 8
- Zeldin previews the rollback at an oil and gas industry conference in Santa Fe 3
- EPA formally proposes a wide-scale reconsideration of the 2024 methane rule 2
- EPA opens two days of virtual public hearings on the proposal, running through Nov. 17 2
Republish this story on your site or in your newsletter
Any site, blog or newsletter may run this story free of charge. Keep the credit line and its link to the original, do not sell it, and edit only for length or house style (the full terms). Photos carry their own licenses, noted under each photo on this page, so use the text alone unless a credit says otherwise.
Paste it into your editor's HTML view. The one-pixel image at the end tells our newsroom the story ran; it stores no reader data.
Sources
- CleanTechnica, “Environmental, Public Health Experts Testify During Public Hearings on Methane Pollution Rollback Proposal” (2026-11-16). cleantechnica.com/2026/11/16/environmental-public-health-exp
- U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, “2026 Actions to Reduce Burden on the Oil and Natural Gas Industry” (2026-11-16). epa.gov/controlling-air-pollution-oil-and-natural-gas-operat
- Santa Fe New Mexican, “EPA head visiting Santa Fe announces sweeping oil and gas regulation rollback” (2026-10-07). santafenewmexican.com/news/local_news/epa-head-visiting-sant
- KRQE (via Yahoo News), “EPA administrator announces proposal to rollback methane emission rules” (2026-10-07). yahoo.com/news/politics/articles/epa-administrator-announces
- Mother Jones, “The EPA Is About to Hand Oil and Gas Companies a Huge Methane-Related Gift” (2026-10-14). motherjones.com/environment/2026/10/epa-zeldin-methane-emiss
- Medical Daily, “EPA Methane Rollback Could Add 17 Million Tons of Smog-Forming Pollution From Oil and Gas Wells by 2050” (2026-10-29). medicaldaily.com/epa-methane-rule-rollback-pollution-health-
- Holland & Knight, “EPA Proposes Significant Revisions to Oil and Natural Gas Methane Standards Under Clean Air Act” (2026-11-01). hklaw.com/en/insights/publications/2026/11/epa-proposes-sign
- Environmental Defense Fund, “Statement: EPA's methane repeal would put polluters first and waste America's energy” (2026-10-07). edf.org/media/statement-epas-methane-repeal-would-put-pollut
- Maine Beacon, “EPA methane proposal threatens Maine's public health, climate goals” (2026-11-12). mainebeacon.com/epa-methane-proposal-threatens-maines-public
- Earthjustice, “Guide to Public Hearing on Methane Regulations Rollback” (2026-11-10). earthjustice.org/feature/public-hearing-methane-regulations-
Found an error? Tell the newsroom. Corrections are noted at the top of the story.
More from the files
EPA's own analysis says methane rollback trims oil 11 cents a barrel, adds pollution
Trump says loosening methane leak rules for oil and gas wells will cost less. The EPA's numbers show crude oil would drop about 0.14% in 2027, while the rollback would add millions of tons of smog-forming and toxic pollution through 2050.
Trump EPA moves to ease methane leak rules for oil wells a week before the midterms
The plan would relax leak rules for small oil and gas wells, end a program that flags big methane releases, and loosen limits on routine flaring. The White House said Trump would announce it Tuesday at a Texas rally for Ken Paxton. The administration promises $45 billion in savings, but those figures come only from the administration.
Forever chemicals found in tap water for 197 million as EPA moves to drop four limits
A new analysis of federal and state testing finds PFAS chemicals in water systems serving 197 million Americans, 23 million more than federal testing alone showed. It comes as the Trump EPA works to throw out limits on four of these chemicals and give some utilities more time on the other two.
Delivered free to your door*
The Morning Edition
One short email at 7 a.m. Eastern: the day's top files, one clip worth your time, and the race to watch. Plain English, large type, no clutter.
*Your inbox. Free. Unsubscribe with one click, any time.








