Voting Rights · Explainer · File No. 261115-859
Pennsylvania Democrats' new trifecta puts early voting and faster mail counts on the table
Democrats won the Pennsylvania Senate and kept the governor's office, giving them full control of state government. That could end years of gridlock over how the state runs its elections, including mail ballots, early voting and voter ID.
Every quote in this story (4) was matched word for word against its source. How we work

Pennsylvania Democrats will soon control the governor's office, the state House and the state Senate. That means changes to the state's election laws, which have been stuck for years, could finally move. Democratic lawmakers say voting rules will be near the top of their list next session 1.
Democrats flipped the state Senate on Nov. 3 and now hold a 26-24 majority. Gov. Josh Shapiro also won reelection 2. Before the election, Republicans held the Senate 27-23. Democrats had not controlled both chambers and the governorship at the same time since 1993 3.
There were two things on the ballot last Tuesday: the economy and democracy,
Why Pennsylvania's election rules have been stuck
Pennsylvania's 2019 mail voting law, called Act 77, let any voter cast a ballot by mail without giving a reason 2. But it had two big gaps. It did not give county election offices time to "precanvass," meaning open and prepare mail ballots before Election Day. And it left the rules unclear for fixing mistakes, such as a voter forgetting to write the date on the return envelope 1.
Because counties cannot open mail ballot envelopes until Election Day, their staff are stretched thin, and that helped slow the results in 2020 1. Fights over undated envelopes and other errors grew as more people voted by mail. With lawmakers deadlocked, courts have settled many of those fights instead of the legislature 1.
From Channel GOPJosh Shapiro declares victory in PennsylvaniaJosh Shapiro · 15 plays · captioned, with the source named
Under divided government, Republicans would not pass election bills unless they came with a state constitutional amendment requiring stricter voter ID. Democrats never agreed to that 1. In 2025, Senate Majority Leader Joe Pittman said Democrats passing a voter ID amendment would be the starting point for "the discussion of additional election reforms" 4.
What Democrats say they want
The likely blueprint is a large election bill from House Speaker Joanna McClinton. It passed the House in May 2025 and then died in the Republican Senate 13. It would have created true early in-person voting. That would replace today's clumsy workaround, where voters request a mail ballot and fill it out in person at the county office 1.
McClinton's bill would also have required at least two mail ballot drop boxes in every county, required electronic poll books by 2027, and given counties more time to precanvass. It would have allowed up to $60 million in bonds for voting equipment, plus $2 million to vet the electronic poll books 3.
Other Democrats have their own ideas. State Rep. Scott Conklin plans to bring back a bill giving counties more time to process mail ballots. Senate Democratic leader Jay Costa has shown interest in Election Day voter registration and in letting young people preregister so they can vote once they turn 18. A bill to let unaffiliated voters cast ballots in primaries already passed the House with support from both parties 1.
State Rep. Malcolm Kenyatta, who is also a vice chair of the Democratic National Committee, said election changes will be a "top five" priority, naming early voting and preregistration of young voters 1. Shapiro and state Sen. Maria Collett have said they are open to Pennsylvania joining the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact. That is an agreement among states meant to elect the presidential candidate who wins the most votes nationwide 1.
We want to make it easier for people to vote, but also have a system that has integrity,
Voter ID is off the agenda, for now
Right now, Pennsylvania voters show ID only the first time they vote at a new polling place. So far, Democrats have not listed voter ID in their 2027-2028 agenda 1. In 2025, McClinton and Shapiro said they could back broader voter ID if it did not make voting harder 4. The state has tried four times in two decades to pass a stricter ID law. A 2012 version was struck down in court 4.
Senate Republicans saw it coming. In July, a spokesperson for Senate President Pro Tempore Kim Ward called Republicans the "last line of defense" on several issues, including "safeguarding elections" 3.
Pennsylvanians know [Democratic] policies are detrimental to positioning our Commonwealth for growth,
Counties: new rules need money and staff
County election officials mostly want things to run more smoothly. Kyle Kopko leads the County Commissioners Association of Pennsylvania. He said split government made it hard to negotiate, but "we at least have some more certainty, I think going into the next legislature" 1.
Officials also warn that new duties cost money. Mercer County election director Thad Hall pointed out that 29 counties have two or fewer full-time election workers. Requiring drop boxes to be emptied every day could overload them, he said 1. Laura Anna, the election director in Venango County, said that "Funding is always an issue as we add more and more service, like on-demand voting" 1.
That just puts stress on people. It opens up the possibility we will have Election Day errors,
Democratic leaders have not yet put out a detailed agenda, though Shapiro said one is coming soon. Election law is also competing with other Democratic goals, including mass transit funding, the minimum wage, abortion rights and housing 1.
Our analysis: Pennsylvania's rules for counting mail ballots, fixing honest mistakes and voting early have been decided by courts and gridlock since 2019. That matters because whatever passes in the coming session will probably set the rules counties use in the 2028 presidential election. For the first time in decades, the party that wants to make voting easier does not need Republican votes to do it.
The Record
- Votebeat reports that Senate Majority Leader Joe Pittman wants a voter ID constitutional amendment as the starting point for other election changes 4
- Republicans hold a 27-23 state Senate majority, where Speaker McClinton's House-passed election bill has never come up for a vote 3
- Democrats flip the Pennsylvania Senate to a 26-24 majority as Gov. Josh Shapiro wins reelection 2
- Democratic lawmakers say election changes will be a top priority. Voter ID is not on their 2027-2028 agenda 1
Republish this story on your site or in your newsletter
Any site, blog or newsletter may run this story free of charge. Keep the credit line and its link to the original, do not sell it, and edit only for length or house style (the full terms). Photos carry their own licenses, noted under each photo on this page, so use the text alone unless a credit says otherwise.
Paste it into your editor's HTML view. The one-pixel image at the end tells our newsroom the story ran; it stores no reader data.
Sources
- Votebeat, “How election laws could change now that Democrats are in power in Pennsylvania” (2026-11-13). votebeat.org/pennsylvania/2026/11/13/election-law-legislatur
- The Conversation, “Pennsylvania Democrats now have power to push forward on election reform, marijuana legalization and minimum wage increases” (2026-11-04). theconversation.com/pennsylvania-democrats-now-have-power-to
- Spotlight PA / Votebeat, “Pa. elections could look different if Democrats win full control of state government in 2026” (2026-07-08). spotlightpa.org/news/2026/07/election-law-changes-democratic
- Votebeat / Spotlight PA, “Expanded voter ID remains one of Pennsylvania's most elusive reforms” (2025-05-05). votebeat.org/pennsylvania/2025/05/05/voter-identification-el
Found an error? Tell the newsroom. Corrections are noted at the top of the story.
More from the files
Democrats win 6 new state trifectas and end GOP dominance in many legislatures
Voters ended a Republican grip on statehouses that began in 2010, NPR reports. The change could shape state decisions on Medicaid, abortion, taxes and school funding.
Grid watchdog says data centers have added $29.4 billion to power costs for 67 million
The independent watchdog for the largest U.S. power grid says demand from data centers, many of them not yet built, drove up costs that customers in 13 states and Washington, D.C., will pay. It warns that a December auction could add $5 billion to $10 billion more.
House Democrats weigh 2028 Senate bids, led by Pennsylvania's Fetterman seat
After the Democratic midterm wins, House members are openly weighing runs for Senate seats in 2028. Pennsylvania is the clearest example, and the party sees chances to build on its gains.
Delivered free to your door*
The Morning Edition
One short email at 7 a.m. Eastern: the day's top files, one clip worth your time, and the race to watch. Plain English, large type, no clutter.
*Your inbox. Free. Unsubscribe with one click, any time.





