Then vs. Now · File No. 261118-096
Ron Johnson said in 2023 he wanted to 'save' Social Security. Now he says 'shut it down'
In 2023, Sen. Ron Johnson said he never suggested putting Social Security 'on the chopping block.' On Wednesday, the Senate Budget Committee chairman went on Fox Business and called the program a Ponzi scheme that should be shut down. He said it hours before he was set to chair a hearing on the program's future.
Every quote in this story (4) was matched word for word against its source. How we work

On Wednesday morning, Sen. Ron Johnson, the Wisconsin Republican who chairs the Senate Budget Committee, went on Fox Business and said Social Security cannot be fixed. He called it "a scam" and "grotesque" 1. He said this before a committee hearing on the program's future 1.
It's a Ponzi scheme. You can't fix it; you just shut it down and hope that you can recover some of your money.
Social Security is the federal retirement, survivor and disability program funded by payroll taxes. The "shut it down" line is new. In 2023, Johnson told voters something different.
Then: 'I want to save these programs'
In February 2023, President Joe Biden spoke in Wisconsin. He read aloud a 2022 Johnson quote about moving Social Security and Medicare out of automatic, or mandatory, spending 5. Johnson answered with a statement to Fox News Digital: "President Biden is lying about me. He lied last night, and he lied again today" 5.
I never suggested putting Medicare & Social Security on the chopping block.
In the same statement, Johnson said, "I want to save these programs." He said the biggest threat to them was "out of control debt and deficits" 5.
From Channel GOPWarren asks Greer for a tariff refund planElizabeth Warren · 180 plays · captioned, with the source named
The 2022 remarks were real. According to PolitiFact, Johnson suggested in August 2022 that Medicare and Social Security stop being mandatory spending programs 6. Under that idea, Congress would have to fund them each year through the annual budget process 6. MS NOW reported that this would expose the programs to yearly cuts and end guaranteed, automatic benefits 1.
Now: a report and a hearing
Johnson also wrote a new committee report. Fox News first reported it Wednesday, and its title is "Social Security: The Reality… a Legal Ponzi Scheme" 3. It says the 6.2% Social Security payroll tax taken from workers' pay is not saved for them. Instead, it pays today's retirees or other government programs 3.
Social Security cannot be fundamentally fixed as a retirement investment fund because it never was one
The report projects a Social Security shortfall of about $511 billion in 2032. That would be about 21% of that year's projected $2.4 trillion federal deficit 3. Fox News reported that Johnson has about two more months as committee chairman 3.
The committee scheduled its hearing, called "Social Security: The Reality," for Nov. 18 7. The witnesses were three economists: Veronique de Rugy of George Mason University's Mercatus Center, Jason Fichtner of the LIMRA Retirement Income Institute and Kathryn Anne Edwards of the National Academy of Social Insurance 7. The hearing cannot produce a bill on its own 7.
The fact check on 'Ponzi scheme'
Johnson has used this line for years. PolitiFact rated his 2023 "legal Ponzi scheme" claim Mostly False 6. Unlike a Ponzi scheme, PolitiFact said, Social Security is required to pay benefits. The government must also repay the money it has borrowed from the trust fund, with interest, and the program's finances are public 6.
PolitiFact also found that Johnson changed course on this once before. In 2016, he told a group that he was wrong in 2010 to call Social Security a Ponzi scheme. Then he called it a "legal Ponzi scheme" instead 6.
What the numbers actually say
The money problem is real, but it is smaller than "shut it down" suggests. The retirement trust fund is projected to run out of reserves in late 2032 7. After that, incoming payroll taxes would still cover 78% of scheduled retirement and survivor benefits, so checks would shrink, not stop 7.
Ways to close the gap are already on the table. Right now, Social Security taxes apply only to the first $184,500 a worker earns each year. That limit rises to $192,300 in 2027 7. Sens. Bernie Moreno, an Ohio Republican, and Elizabeth Warren, a Massachusetts Democrat, have proposed a bipartisan plan to lift that cap 4.
Democrats pushed back right away. Sen. Catherine Cortez Masto of Nevada wrote that "Americans have paid into their Social Security with every paycheck" 2.
I'm not going to let Senate Republicans like Ron Johnson gut the benefits seniors have earned across a lifetime of work.
The advocacy group Social Security Works said Social Security "is the most popular and effective program in America" and that Johnson "wants to 'shut it down'" 2.
Why it matters
That matters because Johnson is not a backbencher. As Budget Committee chairman, he controls what the committee examines until Democrats take over in January 3. He also won his 2022 race by about one percentage point, and MS NOW says he appears to be setting up a likely 2028 reelection campaign 1.
The pattern is familiar. In an election year, Johnson called claims that he would cut the program lies. Two weeks after the midterms, he said on national television that you "just shut it down" 15. About 76 million people will get Social Security's 3.6% cost-of-living raise in January, which comes to about $75 a month for the average retiree 7. They now have both statements on the record.
The Record
- Johnson suggests ending Social Security and Medicare as mandatory spending programs, which would make Congress fund them each year, PolitiFact reports 6
- Johnson says Biden is 'lying about me' and says, 'I want to save these programs' 5
- PolitiFact rates Johnson's 'legal Ponzi scheme' claim Mostly False 6
- Johnson releases a report calling Social Security a 'Legal Ponzi Scheme' and says on Fox Business that you 'just shut it down' 13
Republish this story on your site or in your newsletter
Any site, blog or newsletter may run this story free of charge. Keep the credit line and its link to the original, do not sell it, and edit only for length or house style (the full terms). Photos carry their own licenses, noted under each photo on this page, so use the text alone unless a credit says otherwise.
Paste it into your editor's HTML view. The one-pixel image at the end tells our newsroom the story ran; it stores no reader data.
Sources
- MS NOW, “GOP's Ron Johnson condemns Social Security, says he wants to 'shut it down'” (2026-11-18). ms.now/rachel-maddow-show/maddowblog/ron-johnson-social-secu
- Raw Story, “GOP senator startles with Social Security rant: 'Coming to a Democratic ad'” (2026-11-18). rawstory.com/ron-johnson-social-security-2678443527/
- Fox News, “Americans misled on Social Security for decades as clock counts down on benefits, explosive report reveals” (2026-11-18). foxnews.com/politics/americans-misled-social-security-decade
- Yahoo News, “GOP Sen. Calls Social Security A 'Ponzi Scheme': 'Just Shut It Down'” (2026-11-18). yahoo.com/news/politics/articles/gop-sen-calls-social-securi
- Fox News, “Sen. Ron Johnson says Biden is lying about him, references 1975 proposal to cut Social Security, Medicare” (2023-02-09). noticias.foxnews.com/politics/sen-ron-johnson-says-biden-lyi
- PolitiFact, “Sen. Ron Johnson again says Social Security is a Ponzi scheme” (2023-05-05). politifact.com/factchecks/2023/may/05/ron-johnson/sen-ron-jo
- Legis1, “Senate to Examine Social Security as Trust Fund Crisis Nears” (2026-11-12). legis1.com/news/social-security-benefits-budget-committee-wi
Found an error? Tell the newsroom. Corrections are noted at the top of the story.
More from the files
Ron Johnson, who calls Social Security a 'legal Ponzi scheme,' holds hearing Wednesday
The Senate Budget Committee chairman will lead a hearing called "Social Security: The Reality" on Nov. 18. The trust fund behind retirement checks is projected to run short in late 2032, and Johnson's party loses its Senate majority in January.
AARP: Social Security could pay full benefits to 2059 if its tax base had kept pace
A new AARP study says the share of the economy taxed for Social Security has shrunk over 40 years, costing the program $10.8 trillion. That shifts the blame for the coming shortfall away from retirees and points to the tax cap, as lawmakers argue over cutting benefits or raising revenue.
Wyden says 'a lot' of interest in lifting Social Security tax cap, some from GOP
Sen. Ron Wyden, the incoming Senate Finance chair, says lifting the payroll tax cap has growing support. Without action, Social Security's main trust fund can pay only 78 percent of benefits starting in late 2032.
Delivered free to your door*
The Morning Edition
One short email at 7 a.m. Eastern: the day's top files, one clip worth your time, and the race to watch. Plain English, large type, no clutter.
*Your inbox. Free. Unsubscribe with one click, any time.





