Courts & Justice · Report · File No. 261116-112
Supreme Court won't hear California bias-training case; Thomas, Alito dissent
The justices turned away a doctor's challenge to California's implicit bias training rule for physicians on Monday. Thomas and Alito dissented, and Gorsuch would have taken the case, so the speech fight over state licensing rules is likely to return.
Every quote in this story (2) was matched word for word against its source. How we work

The Supreme Court on Monday declined to review California's requirement that doctors' continuing education courses cover implicit bias. The court's docket says only "Petition DENIED" 2. Because the justices did not take the case, the lower court rulings stay in place 1.
There were no arguments in this case. The conservative justices spoke through dissents. Justice Clarence Thomas wrote one, and Justice Samuel Alito joined it. Justice Neil Gorsuch said he would have granted the petition 12.
What the dispute is about
California's law, known as AB 241, requires doctors to complete at least 50 hours of continuing medical education every two years. Since 2022, every course involving direct patient care must address how implicit bias contributes to poorer health outcomes for racial and ethnic minorities, according to KFF Health News 3.
Azadeh Khatibi, an ophthalmologist who teaches continuing education, and the nonprofit Do No Harm sued, saying the rule violates the First Amendment 13. Two lower courts dismissed the suit. They found the requirement was government speech, which is exempt from First Amendment review 1.
From Channel GOPPatel pressed on Trump in Epstein filesRep. from California · 56K plays · captioned, with the source named
A three-judge panel of the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the rule in July 2025 3. The appeals court said California was using its education requirements to communicate its views on medical practices, even though private instructors teach the courses 1.
What Thomas wrote
Thomas argued the lower courts stretched the government-speech doctrine too far. He said the high court needs to revisit it 1. He warned that the same logic could let California require instructors to deliver the state's preferred message on abortion access or the ethics of gender-affirming surgery 1.
We should not permit the government-speech doctrine to be wielded as ‘a cover for censorship’ or a cloak for compelled speech.
Thomas said the key question is whether the government is speaking or is regulating private expression 1. The plaintiffs' complaint does not dispute that the state can require doctors to learn about unconscious bias. It argues the state cannot require every teacher to discuss it in every course 3.
The other side
Defenders of the law say it is aimed at better care. Rep. Sydney Kamlager-Dove, a California Democrat who wrote the bill as a state Assembly member, said the law works by connecting providers to training 3.
By connecting every provider to consistent and evolving training,
Legal experts disagree about the case. Erwin Chemerinsky, dean of UC-Berkeley's law school, called the appeals ruling "clearly correct." A UC Davis law professor, Ashutosh Bhagwat, said the plaintiffs' case was not strong but disagreed that the training counts as government speech 3.
What happens next
Nothing changes for California doctors right now. The rule stays in force 1. Three of the nine justices have signaled interest, though, and a case with a similar issue could return to the court. The pattern is that Thomas often uses dissents to invite future test cases. He did so again Monday in a separate gun case, writing that the court should in an appropriate case consider whether particular sensitive-place gun laws fit the right to public carry 1.
That matters beyond California. States license doctors, nurses and other professionals and set their training rules. A future ruling on where regulation ends and private speech begins could affect those rules in every state.
The Record
- California's AB 241 begins requiring implicit bias content in continuing medical education courses involving direct patient care 3.
- A 9th Circuit panel upholds the requirement as government speech 3.
- The Supreme Court denies review; Thomas and Alito dissent and Gorsuch would have granted the petition 12.
Republish this story on your site or in your newsletter
Any site, blog or newsletter may run this story free of charge. Keep the credit line and its link to the original, do not sell it, and edit only for length or house style (the full terms). Photos carry their own licenses, noted under each photo on this page, so use the text alone unless a credit says otherwise.
Paste it into your editor's HTML view. The one-pixel image at the end tells our newsroom the story ran; it stores no reader data.
Sources
- Courthouse News, “Conservative justices push for crackdown on implicit bias training” (2026-11-16). courthousenews.com/conservative-justices-push-for-crackdown-
- Supreme Court of the United States, “Docket for No. 25-1240, Khatibi v. Yip” (2026-11-16). supremecourt.gov/search.aspx?filename=/docket/docketfiles/ht
- KFF Health News, “Affirmative Action Critics Refuse To Back Down in Fight Over Medical Bias Training” (2025-09-11). kffhealthnews.org/news/article/dei-critics-medical-affirmati
Found an error? Tell the newsroom. Corrections are noted at the top of the story.
More from the files
Schumer vows Democrats will block any 'right-winger' Trump picks for Supreme Court
Senate Democratic Leader Chuck Schumer says Democrats won't allow a 'right-winger' on the high court once they hold the Senate. That could put pressure on Justices Alito and Thomas to decide soon whether to retire.
Alito warns Congress can 'turn off the lights' at Supreme Court as Democrats take over
Speaking to conservative lawyers less than two weeks after Democrats won Congress, Justice Samuel Alito said lawmakers could stop the court by cutting off its money. He also faulted the lower-court judges who have blocked Trump's policies. Democrats are preparing investigations of the court and bills on ethics rules, term limits and adding justices.
Supreme Court won't hear challenge to Maryland gun ban; Thomas signals future fight
The justices turned away a broad challenge to Maryland's limits on carrying guns in 'sensitive places,' so the law stays in force. Justice Clarence Thomas said the court should take up a narrower case later.
Delivered free to your door*
The Morning Edition
One short email at 7 a.m. Eastern: the day's top files, one clip worth your time, and the race to watch. Plain English, large type, no clutter.
*Your inbox. Free. Unsubscribe with one click, any time.





