Voting Rights · Report · File No. 261122-651
Utah Democrats won more House votes than Republicans but just one of four seats
Final counts show Utah Democrats got about 5,900 more votes for the U.S. House than Republicans did, yet the GOP still holds three of the state's four seats. Analyses of the results also suggest the old Republican-drawn map, which a judge threw out, might have given Democrats as many as two seats.
Every quote in this story (4) was matched word for word against its source. How we work

In Utah's Nov. 3 races for the U.S. House, Democratic candidates got more votes than Republican candidates. They still won only one of the state's four seats. The Salt Lake Tribune's tally of the final results puts Democrats at 491,225 votes and Republicans at 485,346, a lead of nearly 6,000 votes 1.
Democrat Ben McAdams won the one seat that changed hands, the 1st District, centered on Salt Lake County 14. Republicans Blake Moore, Celeste Maloy and Mike Kennedy held the other three 4. Under the current map, McAdams won by about 45 points. Moore won by about 7, Kennedy by 13 and Maloy by 21 3.
That matters because the gap between votes and seats is the central question in Utah's eight-year fight over who draws its political maps. Making a district's lines match the result its map-makers want is called gerrymandering.
A map voters asked for, and a court imposed
In 2018, Utah voters approved Proposition 4. The ballot measure created an independent redistricting commission and banned partisan gerrymandering 1. It passed by "less than 1%" 6. In 2020, the Republican-led Legislature passed a bill called SB200. It kept the seven-member commission but dropped the requirement that lawmakers vote on the commission's maps and explain their choice 6.
From Channel GOPBen McAdams claims victory in Utah's 1st DistrictBen McAdams · 148 plays · captioned, with the source named
In 2021, lawmakers drew a congressional map that split Salt Lake County four ways 6. Republicans won all four seats under it in 2022 and 2024 2. Groups including the League of Women Voters Utah sued in 2022 6.
In August 2025, Third District Judge Dianna Gibson ruled that SB200 "unconstitutionally impaired" Prop 4, and she threw out the 2021 map 6. Lawmakers offered a replacement. On Nov. 10, 2025, Gibson rejected it as "an extreme partisan outlier" and picked a map drawn by the plaintiffs, with one Democratic-leaning district 36. Republicans spent more than $1.1 million on outside lawyers during the fight 3.
On Feb. 20, 2026, the Utah Supreme Court dismissed the Legislature's appeal on procedural grounds, without deciding whether Gibson was right 7. Senate President Stuart Adams objected in a statement:
Neither the Utah Constitution nor the U.S. Constitution empowers courts to impose a map
Reps. Burgess Owens and Celeste Maloy also challenged the map in federal court, and a three-judge panel heard arguments on Feb. 18 7. Separately, Republicans tried to repeal Prop 4 by a citizen ballot measure, and President Trump endorsed that effort in January 2026 6. It "narrowly failed to gather enough signatures" to make the ballot 5.
The twist: the old map might have helped Democrats more
Political analysts are now asking what the old 2021 map would have produced in a year like this one. Utah Political Watch reporter Bryan Schott laid the 2026 votes over the old district lines. In his analysis, Democrats narrowly lead in two districts, by 2.8 points in the 1st and 3.0 points in the 2nd. Republicans narrowly lead in the 3rd by 1.0 and in the 4th by 2.6 23. Trump carried each of those old districts by 18.7 to 26.1 points in 2024 3.
Schott warns that the exercise has limits. "This is not a claim that Democrats would have won two seats under the old map," he wrote, since candidates, money and turnout would have been different 3. His analysis also found that a Republican-backed alternative map, known as Option C, would have put Democrats ahead in both Salt Lake-area districts 2.
Former Republican state Sen. Dan McCay made the same point on social media 1:
there would be two Democrats elected from Utah to Congress
The pattern is a familiar one this year. Maps drawn to lock in one party's seats do it by spreading that party's voters thinly across many districts, and that can backfire when voters swing hard the other way.
A statewide swing, and a broken supermajority
The swing in Utah was broad. Democrats improved their margins in all 29 counties and won five, including San Juan and Weber, which had been reliably Republican 1. A New York Times analysis cited by KUER found the state's electorate moved 14 points toward Democrats since 2024 4.
A Brigham Young University analysis found that registered Republicans made up 52% of House voters this year, down from 63% in 2024 1. BYU political scientist Quin Monson said independents and loosely attached Republicans moved toward Democrats. He also said "virtually no Republican who identified with the MAGA movement voted for a Democrat for Congress" 1.
In the Legislature, Democrats and unaffiliated candidates won 18 seats. That means Republicans will lose their supermajority in both chambers next year, for the first time since 1998 1. A supermajority is enough votes to override a governor's veto or put a constitutional amendment on the ballot without help from the other party 4.
What comes next
Before the election, McAdams warned that Republican leaders would keep trying to undo Prop 4. GOP leaders had said to expect a constitutional amendment aimed at the redistricting ruling 5.
They are not going to give up until they guarantee themselves ultimate and unaccountable power
With the supermajority gone, Republicans will now need Democratic votes to send any such amendment to voters 4. Election night left McAdams with a challenge for his own party:
Now the responsibility falls to the Utah Democrats to show that we understand the mission
The Record
- Judge Dianna Gibson rules the Legislature unconstitutionally weakened Prop 4 and throws out Utah's 2021 congressional map 67
- Gibson rejects the Legislature's replacement map and adopts the plaintiffs' map, with one Democratic-leaning district 36
- Utah Supreme Court dismisses the Legislature's appeal on procedural grounds, keeping the new map in place for 2026 7
- Democrats win the Salt Lake-based 1st District, and Republicans lose their two-chamber legislative supermajority 14
- Final totals show Democrats got 491,225 U.S. House votes to Republicans' 485,346 in Utah but won one of four seats 1
Republish this story on your site or in your newsletter
Any site, blog or newsletter may run this story free of charge. Keep the credit line and its link to the original, do not sell it, and edit only for length or house style (the full terms). Photos carry their own licenses, noted under each photo on this page, so use the text alone unless a credit says otherwise.
Paste it into your editor's HTML view. The one-pixel image at the end tells our newsroom the story ran; it stores no reader data.
Sources
- The Salt Lake Tribune, “Democrats got more votes in Utah congressional races than the GOP, despite winning only one seat. Here's how many.” (2026-11-21). sltrib.com/news/politics/2026/11/21/democrats-got-more-votes
- Utah Political Watch, “Utah Republicans' least favorite judge may have saved them a House seat” (2026-11-20). utahpolitics.news/p/utah-congressional-map-2026-gibson-rulin
- Utah Political Watch, “How the blue wave would have hit Utah's old congressional map” (2026-11-10). utahpolitics.news/p/utah-blue-wave-old-congressional-map
- KUER, “Utah Republicans confront a new political reality after Election Day” (2026-11-05). kuer.org/politics-government/2026-11-05/utah-democrats-midte
- KUER, “McAdams win could give Utah lawmakers pause on reviving redistricting fight” (2026-07-03). kuer.org/news/2026-07-03/mcadams-win-could-give-utah-lawmake
- Deseret News (via Yahoo News), “How we got here: The 8-year fight over political power in Utah” (2026-02-09). yahoo.com/news/articles/got-8-fight-over-political-040001808
- KUER, “Utah Supreme Court dismisses lawmakers' appeal to stop the new congressional map” (2026-02-20). kuer.org/politics-government/2026-02-20/utah-supreme-court-r
Found an error? Tell the newsroom. Corrections are noted at the top of the story.
More from the files
Utah Gov. Cox says ignoring voters on redistricting cost GOP its legislative supermajority
Utah's Republican governor says his party lost more than a dozen legislative seats partly because lawmakers overrode a voter-approved ban on gerrymandering. He also says he takes some of the blame. That reasoning matters wherever lawmakers have rewritten laws that voters passed themselves.
Missouri Republicans weigh a new House map after voters rejected their last one 62% to 38%
Two weeks after Missouri voters threw out a congressional map that President Trump pushed for, some Republican leaders say lawyers are looking at whether they can try again. A new voter-approved amendment may stand in their way.
Architect of California's Prop 50 map urges Congress to ban mid-decade redistricting
Paul Mitchell drew the map that helped Democrats flip five California House seats. He now says partisan gerrymandering should end everywhere and wants the incoming Congress to set national rules, even as both parties line up new maps for 2028.
Delivered free to your door*
The Morning Edition
One short email at 7 a.m. Eastern: the day's top files, one clip worth your time, and the race to watch. Plain English, large type, no clutter.
*Your inbox. Free. Unsubscribe with one click, any time.






