Courts & Justice · Report · File No. 261116-204
Victims and prosecutors sue to undo Newsom's commutation of 548 death sentences
A legal foundation representing victims' families and district attorneys asked the California Supreme Court to stop Gov. Gavin Newsom's mass commutation. The case will test how far a governor's clemency power reaches.
Every quote in this story (2) was matched word for word against its source. How we work

Crime victims' families and district attorneys have sued in the California Supreme Court to undo Gov. Gavin Newsom's decision to commute every death sentence in the state. The suit was filed Sunday, and the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation announced it Monday 1.
Newsom announced on Nov. 5 that he would change the sentences of all 548 people on death row to life in prison without the possibility of parole 12. Newsom is a Democrat. He leaves office in January after two terms, and he put a hold on executions in 2019 1.
What the plaintiffs claim
The foundation says Newsom had to give formal notice to district attorneys before commuting the sentences. It also says state law gives crime victims a chance to speak before a governor can commute a sentence, and that Newsom gave them none 1.
The plaintiffs also say Newsom did not review each case on its own. They say he made a categorical decision based on his general opposition to the death penalty, apart from checking whether each inmate had more than one felony conviction 1. They say they have found at least one inmate with two felony convictions who is listed with only one 1.
From Channel GOPNewsom lists Trump family's crypto and contract windfallsGavin Newsom · 204 plays · captioned, with the source named
The governor’s clemency power does not authorize mass commutations that disregard constitutional safeguards, legally required procedures or victims’ rights.
The foundation asks the court to stop Newsom and the state prison agency from acting on the announcement. It also asks the court to order them to explain why it should not grant permanent relief 1.
Why the court is already involved
The state constitution requires a recommendation from at least four of the California Supreme Court's justices before a governor can commute the sentence of someone with more than one felony conviction 23. Newsom has asked the court for recommendations on 382 of the cases, and he wants them by the end of the year 2. The plaintiffs say that process shows why individual review matters 1.
Newsom has said he alone bears responsibility for the decision 2. He has argued that state-sanctioned killing is incompatible with California's values 2. The plaintiffs say his personal views were allowed to override the work of jurors and judges 1.
I follow the moral leadership of past presidents, including our Founding Fathers, and governors across America, from all political parties, who used their executive authority to commute death sentences,
Newsom's office did not answer the lawsuit directly. It pointed Courthouse News to his Nov. 5 statement 1.
What happens next
The court has not ruled on the lawsuit. The justices must also decide whether to give the recommendations Newsom requested on the 382 cases, which need four votes 23.
That matters because the dispute is now partly about law, not just politics. The plaintiffs argue that clemency has procedural limits. Newsom points to governors from both parties who have commuted death sentences 1. Those governors' actions are the precedent he cites, and the court may have to decide how far they go.
The Record
- Newsom imposed a moratorium on executions in California 12.
- Newsom announced he would commute all 548 death sentences to life without parole and asked the California Supreme Court to weigh in on 382 cases 12.
- Victims' families and district attorneys filed suit at the California Supreme Court, announced Nov. 16 1.
Republish this story on your site or in your newsletter
Any site, blog or newsletter may run this story free of charge. Keep the credit line and its link to the original, do not sell it, and edit only for length or house style (the full terms). Photos carry their own licenses, noted under each photo on this page, so use the text alone unless a credit says otherwise.
Paste it into your editor's HTML view. The one-pixel image at the end tells our newsroom the story ran; it stores no reader data.
Sources
- Courthouse News, “Victims, prosecutors sue over California death row commutations” (2026-11-16). courthousenews.com/victims-prosecutors-sue-over-california-d
- San Francisco Standard, “Newsom plans to commute all California death sentences” (2026-11-05). sfstandard.com/2026/11/05/newsom-commute-death-sentencescali
- Law Commentary, “Newsom to commute 548 California death sentences” (2026-11-05). lawcommentary.com/articles/newsom-commute-548-california-dea
Found an error? Tell the newsroom. Corrections are noted at the top of the story.
More from the files
Trump calls Newsom's plan to empty California's death row a 'disaster,' urges reversal
On Saturday, President Trump attacked Gov. Gavin Newsom's plan to turn all 548 California death sentences into life without parole and said he hopes it is overturned. The state Supreme Court, not the White House, has to approve most of the cases before the plan takes effect.
Newsom moves to commute all 548 California death sentences before Becerra takes office
Gov. Gavin Newsom said Nov. 5 he will turn every California death sentence into life without parole. The state Supreme Court must approve most of them, and critics plan to fight it.
Newsom commutes all California death sentences, converting more than 500 to life without parole
Gov. Gavin Newsom on Thursday commuted every death sentence in California, the nation's largest death row, converting them to life without the possibility of parole. The move blocks any future executions under later governors and reopens the national fight over capital punishment.
Delivered free to your door*
The Morning Edition
One short email at 7 a.m. Eastern: the day's top files, one clip worth your time, and the race to watch. Plain English, large type, no clutter.
*Your inbox. Free. Unsubscribe with one click, any time.


