Voting Rights · Report · File No. 261117-515
23 GOP-led states, Trump's Justice Dept. urge court to revive NH voter citizenship law
A federal judge struck down New Hampshire's proof-of-citizenship rule for new voters in May. She found it would hit married women and young people especially hard. Twenty-three Republican-led states and the Justice Department are now asking a federal appeals court to bring the law back.
Every quote in this story (8) was matched word for word against its source. How we work

Twenty-three Republican-led states and President Trump's Justice Department are asking a federal appeals court to bring back a New Hampshire law that made new voters show papers proving U.S. citizenship before they could register 1. A federal judge struck the law down in May 3.
Both filed friend-of-the-court briefs on Friday, Nov. 13. A friend-of-the-court brief is a filing from someone who isn't a party to the case. The briefs went to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit, which hears federal appeals from New England 1. The states argued that the trial judge made a mistake by weighing the law's burden on certain groups, including young voters and married women whose papers show a former name, instead of on all voters 1. They called gathering the documents an ordinary inconvenience 1.
That matters to many married women. The judge found that a woman's birth certificate may not match the name she uses after marriage. She also found that the state's records system has no marriage records to clear up the mismatch 4.
What the law did
The law, House Bill 1569, was signed in 2024 by then-Gov. Chris Sununu, a Republican. It took effect a week after the 2024 presidential election 49. It required first-time registrants to show a birth certificate, a U.S. passport or naturalization papers 4.
From Channel GOPChris Pappas declares victory in New HampshireChris Pappas · 194 plays · captioned, with the source named
It also ended the "qualified voter affidavit." That was a sworn statement letting people without those papers sign that they were citizens, at the risk of voter fraud charges if they lied 34. Seventeen percent of first-time registrants in 2024 used an affidavit 3. More than 10,000 first-time voters used one to register on Election Day 2024 2.
Voters who are already registered in New Hampshire were not affected beyond the state's existing ID rule 2. The law was aimed at people registering for the first time.
What the judge found
U.S. District Judge Samantha Elliott ruled on May 28 in a 98-page decision that followed a nine-day trial 23. She held that the law violated the First and 14th Amendments to the Constitution 3. Based on expert testimony, she estimated that between 5,433 and 31,291 eligible voters lack citizenship documents. The highest estimate was 59,583 4.
will have a particularly detrimental impact on young residents and married women.
Testimony showed that nearly 40% of people don't have a U.S. passport 2. About 60% of New Hampshire registrants were born in another state, so the state's own birth records can't confirm their citizenship 4. Plaintiffs presented evidence that hundreds of voters were turned away in 2024 because they lacked the documents 8. Nearly two dozen were turned away in Concord's 2025 city elections 9.
Priorities USA backed one of the lawsuits. It says one of the people turned away in 2025 was an 89-year-old former ward clerk who had voted in the state for more than 70 years 10.
On fraud, the judge found that 8.3 million ballots were cast from 1998 to 2024. In that time there were 47 documented cases of wrongful voting, and eight involved noncitizens 4. Secretary of State David Scanlan testified that noncitizen voting is essentially nonexistent in New Hampshire 2. Elliott wrote that such "miniscule numbers strongly undercut any legitimate concern about election integrity" 8.
The appeal and the Trump administration
The state Attorney General's Office appealed. Elliott refused to pause her ruling on July 22, and the First Circuit refused on Sept. 4 6. That kept the sworn-statement option open for the Sept. 8 primary and the Nov. 3 midterm 39.
In its appeal, the state argues that proving citizenship is a normal burden, not a severe one. It also argues that its interest in preventing fraud justifies the rule 3. A spokesman for the attorney general defended the law when it was struck down 4.
a common-sense approach to voter registration and election administration.
The Justice Department's new brief argues that the judge never found that a careful voter who planned ahead couldn't get one of the documents the state accepts 1. It also warns that the ruling would make it hard for states to change their voting laws later 1.
There is a warning sign for voters. In October, the U.S. Supreme Court let a separate New Hampshire law take effect while it is appealed. That law stops student ID cards from being accepted for voter registration. Justice Jackson dissented 7. A final appeals ruling on the citizenship law was expected to take at least a year, according to New Hampshire Public Radio's June reporting 3.
What voting rights groups and Republicans say
The League of Women Voters of New Hampshire was one of the groups that sued 4. Its president praised the ruling 5.
This decision is a victory for New Hampshire voters and for the fundamental freedom to vote
Rep. Ross Berry, a Republican from Weare who chairs the state House Election Law Committee, criticized Elliott as an unelected judge 8. "The vast majority of Granite Staters support common sense election integrity laws," he said 8.
Danielle Butterfield, president of Priorities USA, blamed the state's majority party: "New Hampshire Republicans didn't just make voting harder" 10. Henry Klementowicz of the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) of New Hampshire, which brought the case, called the law "a clear attack on one of our most fundamental of rights" 59.
Today's ruling is a victory for all Granite State voters.
The pattern is worth watching. This case is about the rules in one small state. Even so, 23 states and the federal government have joined in to defend them 1. If the appeals court sides with them, the ruling could guide other courts weighing paper-proof voting rules. The women and young people the judge said would be hit hardest would carry the cost 14.
The Record
- The ACLU and voting rights groups sue to block HB 1569, New Hampshire's proof-of-citizenship law for new voter registrations 6.
- HB 1569 takes effect, ending the sworn-statement option for proving citizenship 6.
- U.S. District Judge Samantha Elliott rules the law unconstitutional under the First and 14th Amendments 3.
- The First Circuit denies the state's request to pause the ruling while it appeals 6.
- Twenty-three Republican-led states and the Justice Department file briefs urging the First Circuit to revive the law 1.
Republish this story on your site or in your newsletter
Any site, blog or newsletter may run this story free of charge. Keep the credit line and its link to the original, do not sell it, and edit only for length or house style (the full terms). Photos carry their own licenses, noted under each photo on this page, so use the text alone unless a credit says otherwise.
Paste it into your editor's HTML view. The one-pixel image at the end tells our newsroom the story ran; it stores no reader data.
Sources
- Democracy Docket, “GOP argues New Hampshire citizenship law's benefits are greater than burden on women, young voters” (2026-11-16). democracydocket.com/news-alerts/gop-argues-new-hampshire-cit
- NHPR, “A judge struck down NH's 'proof of citizenship' voting law. Here's what to know.” (2026-05-29). nhpr.org/nh-news/2026-05-29/nh-newhampshire-voting-elections
- NHPR, “Weeks before election, state appeals ruling striking down proof-of-citizenship voting law” (2026-06-25). nhpr.org/politics/2026-06-25/state-appeals-ruling-striking-d
- New Hampshire Bulletin (via Yahoo News), “Ahead of midterms, federal court strikes down NH proof-of-citizenship voter registration law” (2026-05-29). yahoo.com/news/politics/articles/ahead-midterms-federal-cour
- ACLU of New Hampshire, “VICTORY: Court Declares NH Anti-Voter Law Unconstitutional” (2026-05-29). aclu-nh.org/press-releases/victory-court-declares-nh-anti-vo
- ACLU of New Hampshire, “Coalition for Open Democracy, et al. v. David Scanlan, et al. (case page)” (2026-09-04). aclu-nh.org/cases/coalition-open-democracy-et-al-v-david-sca
- Supreme Court Case Tracker, “Scanlan v. Coalition for Open Democracy, emergency application 26A512” (2026-10-22). supremecourtcasetracker.com/emergency-docket/26a512
- InDepthNH, “Federal Judge Strikes Down Voter Registration Restriction Law” (2026-05-29). indepthnh.org/2026/05/29/federal-judge-strikes-down-voter-re
- Concord Monitor, “Federal judge strikes down N.H. voter ID law; repeal of affidavits ruled unconstitutional” (2026-05-29). concordmonitor.com/2026/05/29/federal-judge-strikes-down-n-h
- Priorities USA, “Court Strikes Down New Hampshire's Voter Suppression Law, Restoring Rights for Tens of Thousands of Granite State Voters” (2026-06-01). priorities.org/memos/nh-voter-suppression-law-struck-down/
Found an error? Tell the newsroom. Corrections are noted at the top of the story.
More from the files
Election experts urge appeals court to end Trump DOJ suit over Alaska Senate count
A former Arizona election official and a team of election law scholars filed friend-of-the-court briefs Friday. They want the Ninth Circuit to stop the Justice Department's attempt to hold up certification of Alaska's Senate race, where Democrat Mary Peltola leads. The case tests whether Washington can step into a state's vote count after the ballots are cast.
Trump's Justice Department vows to keep up its voter roll push despite losing in court
Attorney General Todd Blanche says investigations into 'election integrity' will go on after the midterms. Grand jury subpoenas to California counties are still in force, even though the department has lost every court case it brought for full state voter files.
U.S. attorney for Arizona opens probe of three groups over registration claims
Federal prosecutors have sent a case about three Arizona nonprofits to the FBI days before the midterms. No charges have been reported, and one of the groups is a Democratic organization.
Delivered free to your door*
The Morning Edition
One short email at 7 a.m. Eastern: the day's top files, one clip worth your time, and the race to watch. Plain English, large type, no clutter.
*Your inbox. Free. Unsubscribe with one click, any time.








