FCC chair defends warning on 'fake polls' but names no station that aired one

The chairman of the Federal Communications Commission (FCC), the agency whose licenses broadcasters operate under, stood by his warning Thursday that TV and radio stations could break federal rules by airing fake election polls ¹⁴. Pressed by reporters five days before the midterms, Brendan Carr did not identify any station that had broken those rules ¹.

Anna Gomez, the only Democrat on the commission, spoke to reporters separately after the agency's monthly meeting ¹. She said she knew of no FCC investigations involving election polls and argued that the warning is meant to do its work without one ¹².

On tapeForbes Breaking News · Oct 21

▶3:33

I suspect the goal here is the threat itself, a way to spook stations into self-censoring.

A real scandal, and a broad warning

The fight grew out of a genuine problem. A firm called Wedgewood Polling admitted that most of its data was made up after a polling analysis site, FiftyPlusOne, raised questions ³. The firm described the effort as an experiment meant to expose weaknesses in the polling industry ³. The New York Times removed 15 Wedgewood polls from its database, and Decision Desk HQ said it removed 17 ¹⁰.

The damage crossed party lines. Michigan Democrat Mallory McMorrow, who suspended her Senate campaign in July, said a June Wedgewood poll hurt her fundraising and volunteer morale ³. MS NOW cited the firm's polls, and so did the Michigan Senate campaign of Democrat Abdul El-Sayed ¹⁰.

From Channel GOPTalarico asks how Ken Paxton got 15 homesJames Talarico · 153 plays · captioned, with the source named

Carr's response came Oct. 21 in a post on X, the site formerly called Twitter. He claimed a "significant surge in entirely Fake Polls and Suppression Polls" and wrote that "Many journalists and broadcasters have been amplifying or airing these Polls" ⁴¹⁰. He added: "Broadcasters are advised to avoid engaging in News Distortions or running Broadcast Hoaxes" ³. Those are two separate FCC standards, and Carr said stations' federal licenses bar them from violating either one ⁴.

Carr narrows his message

On Thursday, Carr said the warning targets polls that were fabricated, not ordinary reporting on polls ¹². Asked about claims that the FCC would punish anyone who publishes a poll that is bad for a politician, he said: "No, that wasn't what we said" ².

We are reminding broadcasters that they have certain responsibilities that come with their public interest obligations

When reporters asked for examples, Carr acknowledged that none were on the FCC's radar ¹. "I don't know if broadcasters have been specifically airing segments," he said. "They may be." ¹ A review of recent television archives by Straight Arrow News found that MS NOW and NewsNation each cited a Wedgewood poll once ⁹.

Why Gomez and former regulators object

On Oct. 22, Gomez sent a four-page letter to the National Association of Broadcasters, the industry's trade group, urging it to push back harder ⁵. "This administration is running a coordinated, government-wide effort to reshape the media into its sanctioned messenger," she wrote ⁶.

Her legal argument is that the bar for punishing a station is very high. Al Jazeera reported that, as Gomez described it, the standard applies only when a broadcaster knowingly airs false information about a crime or catastrophe that causes immediate and substantial harm ⁵. "Absent that level of clear evidence, the commission has no authority to act," she wrote ⁶. On Thursday, she said reporting a poll that later proves fabricated would not by itself be a violation ¹.

Reporting the results of a poll this Administration happens to dislike does not come close to meeting those standards.

She is not alone. A bipartisan group of former FCC officials, including Mark Fowler, Tom Wheeler and Gloria Tristani, called Carr's threats dangerous and unconstitutional ⁴. They said good-faith reporting on public polls does not violate FCC rules, even when a poll turns out to be made up ⁴. "Brendan Carr is not the journalism police," said Seth Stern of the Freedom of the Press Foundation ⁵.

The timing is what worries critics, and it is worth weighing. When the warning went out, a Reuters/Ipsos poll had President Trump's approval at 31%, and a Washington Post-ABC News-Ipsos poll had it at 33% ⁴. Days earlier, Trump had told reporters, "Look, the polls are fake," while discussing Kansas's Senate race ³. That matters because a warning from the chairman of a licensing agency can carry weight even if no case ever follows.

The ABC fight in the background

Stations have a recent example to look at. In April, the FCC ordered Disney's ABC to file early license renewals for the eight stations it owns, even though those licenses were not due until 2028 at the earliest ⁷. The order came after a Jimmy Kimmel joke about Melania Trump, who called it hateful and violent and urged ABC to act ⁷. Gomez called the order "the most egregious action this FCC has taken in violation of the First Amendment to date" ⁷.

Disney and ABC sued the FCC in federal court in Washington in August ⁸. Their lawsuit says the agency is retaliating against ABC because it disapproves of what the network airs, and it says ABC has become more cautious about booking political candidates ⁸. The suit also points to an FCC investigation of "The View" over equal-time rules and a probe of Disney's diversity practices ⁸. The show's February guest was James Talarico, the Texas lawmaker running for an open U.S. Senate seat ².

Carr said Thursday that the commission is still reviewing documents and petitions opposing the renewals ². "We haven't made a decision about when we're making a decision," he said ².

The trade group has answered Gomez only in general terms, saying it will keep working with policymakers to protect broadcasters' rights ¹. Gomez's closing point to stations was blunt: "the threat only works if the stations let it" ¹. The test between now and Tuesday is whether local newsrooms keep reporting polls as they normally would.

The Record

1. Apr 28, 2026Reports say the FCC ordered Disney's ABC to file early license renewals for its eight owned stations, though the licenses were not due until 2028 at the earliest ⁷.
2. Aug 18, 2026TV Insider reports that Disney and ABC have sued the FCC in federal court, alleging retaliation over what ABC airs ⁸.
3. Oct 21, 2026Carr warns on X that broadcasters could violate their obligations by airing fake polls, after Wedgewood Polling admits fabricating data ³.
4. Oct 22, 2026Gomez sends a four-page letter urging the National Association of Broadcasters to respond more forcefully ⁵.
5. Oct 29, 2026After the FCC's monthly meeting, Carr defends the warning and Gomez calls it a way to spook stations; neither identifies a station that broke the rules ¹².

Sources

1. Inside Audio Marketing, “Carr Clarifies FCC Poll Warning; Gomez Says Threat Remains.” (2026-10-29). insideaudiomarketing.com/post/carr-clarifies-fcc-poll-warnin
2. The Desk, “FCC commissioners clash over election-related poll warnings” (2026-10-29). thedesk.net/2026/10/fcc-commissioners-clash-over-election-re
3. PBS NewsHour, “An alleged national pollster says it faked its data as a 'social experiment.' Here's what to know” (2026-10-21). pbs.org/newshour/politics/a-company-says-its-polls-were-fake
4. TV Technology, “Carr Warns Broadcasters Against Reporting 'Fake' Polls” (2026-10-22). tvtechnology.com/regulatory-legal/fcc/carr-warns-broadcaster
5. Al Jazeera, “FCC Democrat warns broadcasters to resist Trump's media pressure tactics” (2026-10-23). aljazeera.com/economy/2026/10/23/fcc-democrat-warns-broadcas
6. TV Technology, “FCC's Anna Gomez Sounds Alarm Over Election Polling Ahead of Midterms” (2026-10-23). tvtechnology.com/regulatory-legal/fcc/fccs-anna-gomez-sounds
7. NPR via VPM, “FCC orders early license renewal for ABC stations following Kimmel's first lady joke” (2026-04-28). vpm.org/npr-news/npr-news/2026-04-28/fcc-orders-early-licens
8. TV Insider, “Disney & ABC Sue Trump's FCC Amid Threats Against 'The View' and Kimmel” (2026-08-18). tvinsider.com/1282003/disney-abc-sue-trumps-fcc-amid-threats
9. Straight Arrow News, “Fake pollster earlier said 'We encourage reporters to ask us any questions'” (2026-10-22). san.com/cc/fake-pollster-earlier-said-we-encourage-reporters
10. WJLA, “Fake polling firm tricked media, claims fabricated surveys were for 'social experiment'” (2026-10-22). wjla.com/news/nation-world/fake-polling-firm-tricked-media-c

Found an error? Tell the newsroom. Corrections are noted at the top of the story.