Rights & Freedoms · Report · File No. 261120-959
Judge says jailed terrorism defendant can read religious text despite violent passages
A federal judge in New York said prosecutors must let a jailed terrorism defendant read a religious biography, noting the Bible has violent passages too. She stopped short of a formal ruling, but the case tests religious rights behind bars.
Every quote in this story (1) was matched word for word against its source. How we work

A federal judge in New York told prosecutors Thursday that the government must let a man jailed on terrorism charges read religious materials about an important figure in Muslim history, even if some passages advocate violence. Judge Colleen McMahon said similar violent texts in the Bible would never be banned from distribution in jails. 1
McMahon stopped just short of issuing a ruling from the bench. She made her views clear, though. 1
What the judge said
The defendant is Mohammad Baqer Saad Dawood al-Saadi, a dual Iranian-Iraqi national. His lawyer, Andrew Dalack, said the government had denied him a biography of a man who lived 1,300 years ago. McMahon called that man a “seminal figure in Muslim” history. 1
Assistant U.S. Attorney Jeffrey Coyle said the materials, sent by al-Saadi's family, contained passages that “justifies the blood revenge of enemies.” McMahon interrupted him. 1
There are passages in the Bible that could be read the same way.
She cited “statements of immense violence” in the Bible, including passages in the book of Joshua. She also said she did not understand why he had been denied newspaper articles about support for him in Egypt. 1
The materials at issue fall under special administrative measures. These are rules that severely limit al-Saadi's communications with the outside world. McMahon said religious texts do not pose a threat to those measures. 1
The charges
Al-Saadi was charged last week in a rewritten indictment. It accuses him of trying to pass secret messages to Iranian operatives planning an attack on a British air base used by the U.S. Air Force. Prosecutors say he used coded language in calls to his mother and sister in Iraq. 1
Dalack said al-Saadi denies using coded messages. He said the government's case “relies on pure surmise and speculation.” These are allegations, and al-Saadi has not been convicted. 1
In June, al-Saadi pleaded not guilty to charges that he plotted at least 18 attacks in Europe. Prosecutors say he was a commander of Kata'ib Hizballah, a group the U.S. government has designated a foreign terrorist organization. He has been held without bail since. 1
Court records show the dispute over his reading material is not new. At his June arraignment, McMahon told his lawyer that he would get “all his rights” in custody. 2
What happens next
Al-Saadi tried several times to speak directly to the judge. Marshals led him out of the courtroom at one point. McMahon adjourned the case so his family could look for new lawyers, and she set Feb. 10 for his return to court. 1
Coyle said the government is not letting al-Saadi have any more calls with his family. 1
Analysis: This matters beyond one defendant. Religious freedom protections are tested when the person asking is unpopular. A judge saying one faith's scripture cannot be treated more harshly than another's is a reminder that the rules have to apply to everyone, or they protect no one.
The Record
Republish this story on your site or in your newsletter
Any site, blog or newsletter may run this story free of charge. Keep the credit line and its link to the original, do not sell it, and edit only for length or house style (the full terms). Photos carry their own licenses, noted under each photo on this page, so use the text alone unless a credit says otherwise.
Paste it into your editor's HTML view. The one-pixel image at the end tells our newsroom the story ran; it stores no reader data.
Sources
- ABC News (AP), “Judge tells prosecutors that terrorism case defendant can read violent religious passages” (2026-11-20). abcnews.com/US/wireStory/judge-tells-prosecutors-terrorism-c
- Courthouse News Service, “At arraignment, accused Iran-backed terrorist rails against US bombing” (2026-06-01). courthousenews.com/at-arraignment-accused-iran-backed-terror
Found an error? Tell the newsroom. Corrections are noted at the top of the story.
More from the files
Judge blocks ICE from searching phone of immigration lawyer with know-your-rights page
A federal judge in Boston found an immigration lawyer was likely searched because of his speech. She barred the government from reading data copied from his phone, a ruling that matters for lawyers' privacy and free speech.
Researchers ask judge to block NIH screen that flags more than 200 'disfavored' terms
Scientists told a San Francisco federal judge that the National Institutes of Health screens grant applications for words like 'gender' and 'climate change.' The judge signaled that some grant cancellations may be unconstitutional, and he plans to rule by the end of the year.
Judge bars Agriculture Secretary Rollins from religious emails to USDA staff
A federal judge ruled that Brooke Rollins' department-wide Christian emails amounted to coercion of employees. The order matters because it limits how a Cabinet official can use her office and her staff's inboxes.
Delivered free to your door*
The Morning Edition
One short email at 7 a.m. Eastern: the day's top files, one clip worth your time, and the race to watch. Plain English, large type, no clutter.
*Your inbox. Free. Unsubscribe with one click, any time.






