Hinson vows 'hell, no' on Social Security cuts; in 2020 she was open to raising the age

Rep. Ashley Hinson, the Republican running for Iowa's open U.S. Senate seat, has a blunt promise for older voters. A CNBC rundown of Senate races published Sunday repeated it, along with parts of her record that complicate it ¹. She faces Democrat Josh Turek on Tuesday for the seat Sen. Joni Ernst is leaving, in a race MS NOW rates as leaning Republican ¹.

Anyone who's going to propose cuts to Social Security is going to get a 'hell, no' from me.

Hinson has a point on one thing: the record shows no vote by her to cut monthly benefits, and she voted for the Social Security Fairness Act ¹. But the retirement age and the agency's staffing tell a less tidy story. Here is what she said then, what she says now, and what the record shows.

Then: open to raising the age

In December 2020, as a congresswoman-elect, Hinson said she would consider raising the age at which younger Americans could start collecting Social Security ²³. She said any change should be phased in and should not affect current retirees or people close to retirement ²³. She also opposed raising payroll taxes ³.

She was 37 at the time and offered herself as an example. Working longer, she said, was "much easier for me to absorb that than to pull the rug out from under someone who's 62 years old right now" ³.

From Channel GOPTurek: Trump's bill costs 110,000 Iowans health careJosh Turek · 12 plays · captioned, with the source named

Now: a debate answer that left room

At the Oct. 7 Iowa PBS debate, Hinson called for a bipartisan commission ⁴. She also talked about getting young people to save, praised "Trump accounts" and said "Millennials are the worst group of savers in the country right now" ⁴. She did not name a specific change to the program in that answer ⁴.

On the retirement age itself, CNN quoted Hinson from the debate ⁵.

If you're 20 years old, it's a very different conversation than if you're at retirement age

Reports on the debate describe Turek as opposing changes to the retirement age ⁵⁶.

Reporters heard Hinson's answers in different ways. CNN read them as openness to gradually raising the age, now 62, at which people can start collecting ⁵. Dave Price of Iowa's News Now wrote that "Hinson did not directly say whether she would support raising the age to receive full benefits" ⁶. KIWA Radio reported that she said a commission should weigh options, including a higher retirement age for younger Americans ⁷.

CNBC reports that Hinson has since said she opposes raising the age, and that both candidates backed a bipartisan commission at their Oct. 13 debate ¹. Her office did not respond to CNBC's request for comment ¹. That matters because a commission does not settle the question. It hands the hard choice to a panel, and a voter still doesn't know what a Sen. Hinson would do if a higher retirement age came back in its plan.

The people who answer the phones

Benefits are only part of the picture. Someone has to process them. CNBC reports that in 2024, Hinson voted on the House Appropriations Committee to cut Social Security Administration funding ¹. Government Executive reported in June 2024 that House Republicans had proposed a $450 million cut to the agency's administrative budget, which pays for its operations rather than monthly checks ⁸.

A union leader at the agency said the cut would amount to about 3,300 work-years ⁸. Rep. Rosa DeLauro, the top Democrat on the committee, warned it "would mean closings and shorter operating hours at SSA field offices" ⁸. The Gazette of Cedar Rapids reported in September that Hinson's campaign defended her support for a bill cutting agency staffing funds by 4%, saying it would not have reduced benefits ¹¹. The Gazette's report gave no year for that bill ¹¹.

In February 2025, Hinson told the Des Moines Register that the cost-cutting drive known as DOGE was "exactly what the federal government needs" ⁹. Social Security employment fell from 61,869 in 2023 to 49,683 as of January 2026, according to Office of Personnel Management figures cited by KCRG ⁹.

Then came Decorah. The Social Security office there closed for more than six months after its last staff member retired, and seniors needing in-person help had to travel at least 90 minutes each way ⁹. KCRG tied the shortage to the federal workforce cuts ⁹. Hinson says she pressed agency leaders to fix it, and the office reopened in June ⁹.

The fact that this office was closed for six months was unacceptable

The agency says field office wait times have fallen 30% ¹⁰. Former Social Security Commissioner Martin O'Malley, campaigning with Turek, offered a harsher verdict: "Ashley Hinson has damaged Social Security. She voted to cut it." ¹² Her campaign's reply, from Billy Fuerst, was that she "has never and will never cut a penny from Social Security" ¹¹.

The pattern is this: Hinson's defense is about benefits, and her critics' case is about service. Both can be true at once. A check that isn't cut is one thing. A claim that takes longer, or an office 90 minutes away, is a cost too, and it falls on the same people.

What the Social Security tax law does

FactCheck.org, reviewing President Trump's claim that there is no tax on Social Security, found that the law did not eliminate all taxes on Social Security ¹⁴. What it created is a $6,000 deduction for people 65 and older, whether or not they receive benefits ¹⁴. It phases out at incomes of $75,000 for individuals or $150,000 for joint filers and expires after 2028 ¹⁴.

What Turek offers, and what is at stake

Social Security's retirement trust fund could run out in the fourth quarter of 2032, CNBC reports, leaving 78% of benefits payable unless Congress acts ¹. Turek says "one of the best ways to keep Social Security solvent is we have to remove the cap" ¹¹. That cap means workers now pay Social Security taxes only on the first $184,500 of wages ⁶.

At the debate, Turek said lifting the cap would move things significantly in the right direction, but he did not lay out a second step in that exchange ⁴. So Iowans have one candidate with a named plan and another with a commission and no named plan. They choose Tuesday.

The Record

1. Dec 11, 2020The Gazette reports congresswoman-elect Hinson is open to raising the Social Security retirement age, phased in to spare current and near retirees ².
2. Jun 27, 2024Government Executive reports House Republicans have proposed a $450 million cut to Social Security's administrative budget; CNBC says Hinson voted in committee that year to cut agency funding ⁸¹.
3. Jun 10, 2026The Decorah Social Security office reopens after more than six months closed; Hinson calls the closure unacceptable ⁹.
4. Oct 7, 2026Discussing the retirement age at a debate, Hinson says it is a very different conversation for a 20-year-old; reports describe Turek as opposing changes to the age ⁵⁶.
5. Nov 1, 2026CNBC reports Hinson has since said she opposes raising the age, and repeats her 'hell, no' pledge on cuts ¹.

Free to reprint Republish this story on your site or in your newsletter

Any site, blog or newsletter may run this story free of charge. Keep the credit line and its link to the original, do not sell it, and edit only for length or house style (the full terms). Photos carry their own licenses, noted under each photo on this page, so use the text alone unless a credit says otherwise.

<h2>Hinson vows &#39;hell, no&#39; on Social Security cuts; in 2020 she was open to raising the age</h2> <p><em>By The GOP Files Receipts Desk. This article first appeared on <a href="https://thegopfiles.com/story/hinson-vows-hell-no-on-social-security-cuts-in-2020-she-was-open-to-raising-the">The GOP Files</a> on Sunday, November 1, 2026.</em></p> <p>Rep. Ashley Hinson, the Republican running for Iowa&#39;s open U.S. Senate seat, has a blunt promise for older voters. A CNBC rundown of Senate races published Sunday repeated it, along with parts of her record that complicate it . She faces Democrat Josh Turek on Tuesday for the seat Sen. Joni Ernst is leaving, in a race MS NOW rates as leaning Republican .</p> <blockquote><p>Anyone who&#39;s going to propose cuts to Social Security is going to get a &#39;hell, no&#39; from me.</p><p>&mdash; Ashley Hinson, U.S. representative, R-Iowa, Senate candidate</p></blockquote> <p>Hinson has a point on one thing: the record shows no vote by her to cut monthly benefits, and she voted for the Social Security Fairness Act . But the retirement age and the agency&#39;s staffing tell a less tidy story. Here is what she said then, what she says now, and what the record shows.</p> <h2>Then: open to raising the age</h2> <p>In December 2020, as a congresswoman-elect, Hinson said she would consider raising the age at which younger Americans could start collecting Social Security . She said any change should be phased in and should not affect current retirees or people close to retirement . She also opposed raising payroll taxes .</p> <p>She was 37 at the time and offered herself as an example. Working longer, she said, was &quot;much easier for me to absorb that than to pull the rug out from under someone who&#39;s 62 years old right now&quot; .</p> <h2>Now: a debate answer that left room</h2> <p>At the Oct. 7 Iowa PBS debate, Hinson called for a bipartisan commission . She also talked about getting young people to save, praised &quot;Trump accounts&quot; and said &quot;Millennials are the worst group of savers in the country right now&quot; . She did not name a specific change to the program in that answer .</p> <p>On the retirement age itself, CNN quoted Hinson from the debate .</p> <blockquote><p>If you&#39;re 20 years old, it&#39;s a very different conversation than if you&#39;re at retirement age</p><p>&mdash; Ashley Hinson, U.S. representative, R-Iowa, Senate candidate</p></blockquote> <p>Reports on the debate describe Turek as opposing changes to the retirement age .</p> <p>Reporters heard Hinson&#39;s answers in different ways. CNN read them as openness to gradually raising the age, now 62, at which people can start collecting . Dave Price of Iowa&#39;s News Now wrote that &quot;Hinson did not directly say whether she would support raising the age to receive full benefits&quot; . KIWA Radio reported that she said a commission should weigh options, including a higher retirement age for younger Americans .</p> <p>CNBC reports that Hinson has since said she opposes raising the age, and that both candidates backed a bipartisan commission at their Oct. 13 debate . Her office did not respond to CNBC&#39;s request for comment . That matters because a commission does not settle the question. It hands the hard choice to a panel, and a voter still doesn&#39;t know what a Sen. Hinson would do if a higher retirement age came back in its plan.</p> <h2>The people who answer the phones</h2> <p>Benefits are only part of the picture. Someone has to process them. CNBC reports that in 2024, Hinson voted on the House Appropriations Committee to cut Social Security Administration funding . Government Executive reported in June 2024 that House Republicans had proposed a $450 million cut to the agency&#39;s administrative budget, which pays for its operations rather than monthly checks .</p> <p>A union leader at the agency said the cut would amount to about 3,300 work-years . Rep. Rosa DeLauro, the top Democrat on the committee, warned it &quot;would mean closings and shorter operating hours at SSA field offices&quot; . The Gazette of Cedar Rapids reported in September that Hinson&#39;s campaign defended her support for a bill cutting agency staffing funds by 4%, saying it would not have reduced benefits . The Gazette&#39;s report gave no year for that bill .</p> <p>In February 2025, Hinson told the Des Moines Register that the cost-cutting drive known as DOGE was &quot;exactly what the federal government needs&quot; . Social Security employment fell from 61,869 in 2023 to 49,683 as of January 2026, according to Office of Personnel Management figures cited by KCRG .</p> <p>Then came Decorah. The Social Security office there closed for more than six months after its last staff member retired, and seniors needing in-person help had to travel at least 90 minutes each way . KCRG tied the shortage to the federal workforce cuts . Hinson says she pressed agency leaders to fix it, and the office reopened in June .</p> <blockquote><p>The fact that this office was closed for six months was unacceptable</p><p>&mdash; Ashley Hinson, U.S. representative, R-Iowa, Senate candidate</p></blockquote> <p>The agency says field office wait times have fallen 30% . Former Social Security Commissioner Martin O&#39;Malley, campaigning with Turek, offered a harsher verdict: &quot;Ashley Hinson has damaged Social Security. She voted to cut it.&quot; Her campaign&#39;s reply, from Billy Fuerst, was that she &quot;has never and will never cut a penny from Social Security&quot; .</p> <p>The pattern is this: Hinson&#39;s defense is about benefits, and her critics&#39; case is about service. Both can be true at once. A check that isn&#39;t cut is one thing. A claim that takes longer, or an office 90 minutes away, is a cost too, and it falls on the same people.</p> <h2>What the Social Security tax law does</h2> <p>FactCheck.org, reviewing President Trump&#39;s claim that there is no tax on Social Security, found that the law did not eliminate all taxes on Social Security . What it created is a $6,000 deduction for people 65 and older, whether or not they receive benefits . It phases out at incomes of $75,000 for individuals or $150,000 for joint filers and expires after 2028 .</p> <h2>What Turek offers, and what is at stake</h2> <p>Social Security&#39;s retirement trust fund could run out in the fourth quarter of 2032, CNBC reports, leaving 78% of benefits payable unless Congress acts . Turek says &quot;one of the best ways to keep Social Security solvent is we have to remove the cap&quot; . That cap means workers now pay Social Security taxes only on the first $184,500 of wages .</p> <p>At the debate, Turek said lifting the cap would move things significantly in the right direction, but he did not lay out a second step in that exchange . So Iowans have one candidate with a named plan and another with a commission and no named plan. They choose Tuesday.</p> <p><em>Read the original, with every source linked, at <a href="https://thegopfiles.com/story/hinson-vows-hell-no-on-social-security-cuts-in-2020-she-was-open-to-raising-the">thegopfiles.com</a>. Republished under The GOP Files' <a href="https://thegopfiles.com/republish">free republishing terms</a>.</em></p> <img src="https://thegopfiles.com/api/rp/hinson-vows-hell-no-on-social-security-cuts-in-2020-she-was-open-to-raising-the.gif" alt="" width="1" height="1" style="border:0;width:1px;height:1px">

Copy the HTML Paste it into your editor's HTML view. The one-pixel image at the end tells our newsroom the story ran; it stores no reader data.

Sources

1. CNBC, “These Senate races may help determine the fate of Social Security” (2026-11-01). cnbc.com/2026/11/01/social-security-senate-races.html
2. The Gazette, “Ashley Hinson 'open' to raising Social Security retirement age” (2020-12-11). thegazette.com/government-politics/ashley-hinson-open-to-rai
3. Radio Iowa, “Hinson open to raising Social Security retirement age” (2020-12-14). radioiowa.com/2020/12/14/hinson-open-to-raising-social-secur
4. Iowa PBS, “Iowa Press Debates: U.S. Senate (transcript)” (2026-10-07). iowapbs.org/shows/iowapress/special/14524/iowa-press-debates
5. CNN via KRDO, “Takeaways from the first Iowa Senate debate” (2026-10-07). krdo.com/politics/cnn-us-politics/2026/10/07/takeaways-from-
6. WOWT, “Where U.S. Senate candidates agreed and disagreed in 1st debate” (2026-10-08). wowt.com/2026/10/08/where-us-senate-candidates-agreed-disagr
7. KIWA Radio, “Republican Hinson and Democrat Turek Debate” (2026-10-08). kiwaradio.com/news/republican-hinson-and-democrat-turek-deba
8. Government Executive, “Social Security in line for half-billion dollar cut in House GOP funding bill” (2024-06-27). govexec.com/workforce/2024/06/social-security-line-half-bill
9. KCRG, “Social Security "Ghost Office" reopens in Iowa” (2026-06-10). kcrg.com/2026/06/10/social-security-ghost-office-reopens-iow
10. The Iowa Independent, “Hinson celebrates reopening of Social Security office closed by DOGE cuts she supported” (2026-06-15). iowaindependentnews.com/economy/hinson-celebrates-reopening-
11. The Gazette, “Josh Turek, Lindsay James: Eliminate cap on Social Security taxes” (2026-09-09). thegazette.com/news/elections/national/josh-turek-lindsay-ja
12. KTTC, “U.S. Senate candidate Turek wants wealthier people to pay more Social Security taxes” (2026-09-10). kttc.com/2026/09/10/us-senate-candidate-turek-wants-these-pe
13. KTTC, “One-on-one with Iowa U.S. Senate candidate Rep. Ashley Hinson” (2026-10-15). kttc.com/2026/10/15/one-on-one-with-iowa-us-senate-candidate
14. FactCheck.org, “FactChecking Claims from Trump's Midterm Rallies” (2026-10-27). factcheck.org/2026/10/factchecking-claims-from-trumps-midter

Found an error? Tell the newsroom. Corrections are noted at the top of the story.